Brandon Lloyd vs Javon Walker:

It's not like last year was the first year Moss put up good stats though. In 2003, he had 74 catches, 1105 yards and 10 TDs. In 2004 he only had 45 catches, but he did finish with nearly 900 yards receiving (not #1 receiver stats, but I don't think he was the Jets top option that year anyway).

Moss is a player, end of story.

when he hasn't had anything close to the kind of season Moss had last year
I'm saying he could end up our #1, not that he comes in that way. While Moss has had some solid years, he's had some down years and some injuries. I'll continue to be skeptical till I see it for another year, and honestly I don't care what he does as long as we're winning =p

It's not like last year was the first year Moss put up good stats though. In 2003, he had 74 catches, 1105 yards and 10 TDs. In 2004 he only had 45 catches, but he did finish with nearly 900 yards receiving (not #1 receiver stats, but I don't think he was the Jets top option that year anyway).

Remember when he came last year, he noted how Coles had like 90 catches and that if he had that many oppurtunities to catch the ball that he could have easily put up big time numbers. I don't know though if he delivered on that promise. I mean 1483 yards thats like only, 14.8 football fields.

I'm saying he could end up our #1, not that he comes in that way. While Moss has had some solid years, he's had some down years and some injuries. I'll continue to be skeptical till I see it for another year, and honestly I don't care what he does as long as we're winning =p

The great thing about this is that if God fobid Moss gets hurt we'll have a solid Reciever by commitee with Randle El, Lloyd, Patten, Cooley, and Portis (Even though I have a feeling that Patten might get cut if we get Antwan and Lloyd).

Cap wise, we shouldn't sign Randle-EL and Lloyd. Heh! We still have Taylor Jacobs on the roster right?

walker is way better. more expensive, but more productive. i don't think we'll try for or get him though.

javon walker hands down... even coming off of last season's injury.

javon walker hands down... even coming off of last season's injury.Factoring in the injury maybe Lloyd has the edge. I prefer the value of Lloyd either way.

with the picks given up, i don't think you can really call lloyd a "value" unless he's going to come in and put up 1200 yards.