Vince Young Madden 2008 Cover

Well don't forget the 5 rushing TDs as well, and the fact taht under Young the Titans won 5 games in a row (when many didn't even pick them to win 5 all year)

But I think that a lot of the Vince Young "haters" here think that the rest of us have anointed him the heir apparent to great QBs. I can tell you, from my perspective, that's not the case. We're just saying he had a pretty solid rookie year, helped the Titans significantly overachieve, looks to be an exciting and marketable player for years to come and should only get better. Was he the best choice to be on the cover? Probably not, but it's not a bad choice

Ok, point taken good football player, but a terrible QB.

Well don't forget the 5 rushing TDs as well, and the fact taht under Young the Titans won 5 games in a row (when many didn't even pick them to win 5 all year)

FYI, I know this hurts my point, but it was 7 rushing tds.

But I think that a lot of the Vince Young "haters" here think that the rest of us have anointed him the heir apparent to great QBs. I can tell you, from my perspective, that's not the case. We're just saying he had a pretty solid rookie year, helped the Titans significantly overachieve, looks to be an exciting and marketable player for years to come and should only get better. Was he the best choice to be on the cover? Probably not, but it's not a bad choice

It was a team effort, and while Vince's LEGS helped acheive that, his arm didn't help too much at all. He's the next Kordell Stewart. Flashy, and can win with his legs, but when push comes to shove, won't amount to much. I hope he follows the path of McNabb, not Vick. If he follows McNabb, he could be something special...but right now, he's a terrible QB with exceptional scrambling ability.

I don't think the only descriptions of Vince Young have to be terrible or great. Those seem like two extremes that don't really describe him.

I don't think the only descriptions of Vince Young have to be terrible or great. Those seem like two extremes that don't really describe him.

No, right now, he is terrible...he should be working towards greatness. It's about the travel from A to B. If I was a wagering man, I'd say he's not going to make it. He has a TON of work to do to be even a good qb.

Ok, fine. You think he's terrible. Moving on

Ok, fine. You think he's terrible. Moving on

How are we going to move on. Vince Young is what this thread is about.

I dare ya to lock it down.

Ok, fine. You think he's terrible. Moving on

My point wasn't that he was terrible as much as he has a lot of work to do. He can do it, he has the tools...but will he? He's a young kid, with a ton of potential.

My point wasn't that he was terrible as much as he has a lot of work to do. He can do it, he has the tools...but will he? He's a young kid, with a ton of potential.

Which is essentially what I've been saying

either way Jason Campbell will ultimately be better :)

Which is essentially what I've been saying

either way Jason Campbell will ultimately be better :)

Can't argue with that! :food-smil

Can't argue with that:food-smil!
Me neither, where is the beer?
:food-smil