12thMan
09-13-2011, 05:21 PM
I, too, think it's funny that pundits and Giants fans are still whining about missing Osi and Tuck, while completely dismissing how we shut down their downfield passing game and didn't let Jacobs get on a roll.
It's like they forget the other team is paid to play football, until they lose to the Redskins then it's this guy was hurt or that guy was hurt.
artmonkforhallofamein07
09-13-2011, 05:23 PM
Nice Stat Scud...
Giantone... If you are here to talk about how bad we have been in the past.. well keep dwelling on that one. We are here for the present, not what happened the last seven years. To be quite honest there may be another QB starting next year. Who knows... you guys lost to a team that played better, a QB who out performed yours, a defense who dominated you in the second half, and and offense who has had the same starting QB for four games with no OTAs. We won you lost. You should drop it. Eli is who he is. We all know it. He caught lightening in a bottle back in 07. He is not terrible and he is not great.
CrustyRedskin
09-13-2011, 05:31 PM
Hey Rex Grossman is on PTI for 5 good minutes check it out!!!!!! And he did a great job, nice Rexy!!!
Giantone
09-13-2011, 07:40 PM
You know what I think is funny? You said that not having OTA's/offseason hurt Eli and his WRs. Well, there have never been that many passing yards in a single week in NFL history. Didn't hurt anyone else. LOL.
LOLReally,are you sure?How many yards did mcNabb have?I find it funny how mad you're getting when you realise Eli isn't all that bad.
No doubt he stunk Sunday and you guys played great but as a Giant fan I know he can play better.So how many QB's is it?
tryfuhl
09-13-2011, 07:43 PM
lol.....funny coming from a guy who is Good Charlotte's #1 fan.
What?
Giantone
09-13-2011, 07:44 PM
Nice Stat Scud...
Giantone... If you are here to talk about how bad we have been in the past.. well keep dwelling on that one. We are here for the present,.
Nope and I did'nt bring it up all I'm doing is defending Eli,and all I did was ask a question?Find the post I said 1 negative thing about the Skins?
Lotus
09-13-2011, 07:48 PM
You know what I think is funny? You said that not having OTA's/offseason hurt Eli and his WRs. Well, there have never been that many passing yards in a single week in NFL history. Didn't hurt anyone else. LOL.
LOLReally,are you sure?How many yards did mcNabb have?I find it funny how mad you're getting when you realise Eli isn't all that bad. No doubt he stunk Sunday and you guys played great but as a Giant fan I know he can play better.So how many QB's is it?
Ok Giantone, put it this way: following your argument and given first week performances, we should conclude that the lockout hurt Eli more than it hurt the rookie Newton.
Good luck with that.
Giantone
09-13-2011, 07:53 PM
...........yes.Why I don't know but it seems that way.
NC_Skins
09-13-2011, 08:16 PM
I will defend Eli a little bit. Quite a few of those INTs from last year came from tip balls from WRs. Even that INT Sunday was really at the hands of the missed block on the OL. Sucks that QBs have to take the fall for that, but thems the breaks.
artmonkforhallofamein07
09-13-2011, 09:01 PM
Nope and I did'nt bring it up all I'm doing is defending Eli,and all I did was ask a question?Find the post I said 1 negative thing about the Skins?
TO be honest, in my earlier posts I was helping you defend Eli. I do not think he is that bad. I just don't consider him great. He is good, sure. He has a lot of things in place for him to succeed as well. Great D, an awesome Oline, good running game, and good WRs. You guys have always put competitive teams on the field. Your FO is great.
My real point was that the loss of the offseason really should not have effected the Giants as much as you seem to think it has. You guys besides the loss of Boss and an injured Steve Smith are bringing back the same team on offense.
Your biggest losses have come from injuries on the defensive side of the ball during preseason and training camp.
That is your current problem, not Eli or the offense. Give our D some credit, they played a hell of a game. Sometimes it is not how bad you are playing but how good the other unit they are going against is.
I have rewatched the game and we just straight out played you after the second quarter. There really is no doubt about that. Just give our team some credit as you are on a Skins board and be done with it.