Top 10 QBs

I think mine would be:

1 Peyton Manning
2 Aaron Rodgers
3 Drew Brees
4 Tom Brady
5 Eli Manning
6 Ben Roethlisberger
7 Matt Ryan
8 Jay Cutler
9 RG3
10 Matt Stafford


CUTLER? On the list at all is crazy but above Griffin and Stafford? Wow.

Jay and Eli don't belong on the list.

Top Ten:
Peyton
Aaron
Tom
Drew
Ben
Phillip
"Matty"
Colin
Tony
Matthew

I would consider Robert, Andrew, and Russell; but I don't think they've played enough to belong on the list yet.

Jay and Eli don't belong on the list.

Top Ten:
Peyton
Aaron
Tom
Drew
Ben
Phillip
"Matty"
Colin
Tony
Matthew

I would consider Robert, Andrew, and Russell; but I don't think they've played enough to belong on the list yet.


So why Ben but not Eli ?

So why Ben but not Eli ?The pounding Ben has had to take to do what other QBs have done.

Ben is one of many QBs that has looked his best in his non-SB years.

I guess if we were ranking QBs by tendency for interceptions, Brett and Eli would be among the top 5 all time. :)

1. Peyton
2. Brady
3a. Rodgers
3b. Brees
5. Big Ben
6. Eli
7. Matt Ryan
8. Romo
9. Luck
10. Stafford / Rivers

Done from the perspective of "If I had one season to win a Superbowl who would I want as my QB?"

Good thread! Could be done for other positions when this one dies out.

CUTLER? On the list at all is crazy but above Griffin and Stafford? Wow.

Well, Cutler has taken his team, with a crappy OL to the NFC championship game. RG3, nor Stafford have done that. Thats why he is above them on my top 10. Also RG3 being a rookie (for as great a season as it was) was still a rookie last year; can't put him that high on a top 10 list above more established players, especially if he has a bad year this year. And Stafford is injury prone and throws to the best WR in the NFL.

This year after 4/5 games:

1-Manning
2-Brady
3-Rodgers
4-Brees
5-Luck
6-Rivers
7-Romo
8-Ryan
9-Stafford
10-Cutler

(rankings and other QB's will change as the season progresses)

In order of awesomeness:

1) P. Manning
2) Breesus
3) Rodgers
4) Brady
5) Luck
6) Stafford
7) Ryan
8) P. Mannings retarded little brother
9) Wilson
10) Rothlesburger

I hate putting Ben on the list because he's a scumbag, but he's earned it on the field.

Wilson gets the nod because he does everything and in this era of mobile QBs he's doing it the best all around. RG could be there but he's too careless this far, in more ways than one.

Jay and Eli don't belong on the list.

Top Ten:
Peyton
Aaron
Tom
Drew
Ben
Phillip
"Matty"
Colin
Tony
Matthew

I would consider Robert, Andrew, and Russell; but I don't think they've played enough to belong on the list yet.

Why Kapernick over the other three? He has been pretty average at best this year, And until I see more from both III and Wilson neither one belong on this list. The only young guy I would even consider right now is Luck. The other three haven't done much of anything this year. CK also has a smaller sample size of games over the other three. Last years rookies started all 16 games (well minus the one griff missed) and CK started 7 games + the 3 playoff games. And honestly even with Griffin struggles he has been the worst of the 4 this year.

So why Ben but not Eli ?

lol...that train is never late.

Eli is a good QB, but if you look at some of his numbers he is wildly inconsistent and it goes in cycles. Its really strange. He plays like a top 5 QB, leading 4th quarter comebacks and then he will lead the league in interceptions, fumbles, turnovers.

I think Eli is really like most QB, their life is made alot easier with a solid running game and a top half of the league defense.