The annual NFL coaching carousel

Do we want him fired? ;)No although I do like their draft with Carter and Dart. Just don't see him being successful there long term.

I get you're not a Giants fan and I will change no minds here but none of that is true. Mara is giving him and Schoen their contracts Jones was not their call it was Mara's and he knows dumping Coaches every two years won't work.Lawrence and Nabers calling team soft: https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/42590210/giants-players-call-team-soft-question-effort-loss

Giants players losing faith: https://giantswire.usatoday.com/story/sports/nfl/giants/2024/09/20/some-new-york-giants-players-beginning-lose-faith-brian-daboll/75303235007/

Also, Daboll has been head coach there for 3 years not 2. I don't care honestly just want him retained. Pretty unusual to be there that long and have as bad of a season as they did and not get fired. I stand by my theory Mara didn't want to deal with as getting a new head coach as the process can be cumbersome.

Lawrence and Nabers calling team soft: https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/42590210/giants-players-call-team-soft-question-effort-loss

Giants players losing faith: https://giantswire.usatoday.com/story/sports/nfl/giants/2024/09/20/some-new-york-giants-players-beginning-lose-faith-brian-daboll/75303235007/

Also, Daboll has been head coach there for 3 years not 2. I don't care honestly just want him retained. Pretty unusual to be there that long and have as bad of a season as they did and not get fired. I stand by my theory Mara didn't want to deal with as getting a new head coach as the process can be cumbersome.

Point is that the previous 3 coaches never made it past 2 seasons.Since Tom Coughlin departed as the head coach after the 2015 season, the Giants have had five head coaches, including Daboll.

Earlier this year, co-owner John Mara gave Schoen and Daboll a vote of confidence, pretty much telegraphing his future plans. Change for the sake of change is how he got here. Standing pat might be the right strategy this time around.


Your one link is two players questioning the play of fellow teammates I have no problem with players leading in the locker room your link on Daboll is a BS opinion from a reporter who had been in DS with the team. Not sure he even covers them anymore. Like I said not going to change any minds but what you posted wasn't true.


AI,While there isn't a single definitive answer, some New York Giants players have publicly expressed positive opinions of head coach Brian Daboll. Specifically, veteran wide receiver Darius Slayton has voiced support for Daboll and general manager Joe Schoen, suggesting they should be retained for another year to continue their work. Other players have highlighted Daboll's positive impact on the team's culture and his ability to foster a positive environment.

Please stop posting AI results lol

Like I said not going to change any minds but what you posted wasn't true.It is totally on Daboll to create a positive culture within his own team. Players calling out the team as soft and questioning the team's effort is an extraordinary indictment of a coach who isn't getting it done. Again, I don't care if the players like him or not. He has done nothing worthwhile in the NFL and is very fortunate to still be a head coach. Nearly impossible to believe a coach is well liked whose team is being called soft by it's own personnel, questioning fellow teammates effort in games, and losing faith in their coach while winning 3 games total in 1 season.

I am all for Mara putting a halt to the roulette wheel of coaches, as long as the coach is lousy when to ball finds its slot. I don't really have a read on Daboll. He had the team over-performing a couple seasons ago, and he had a dreadful GM in place in the run up to it (and I am not sure the current GM is any good either). Hard to assess the coach when he's hamstrung like that. Having said all that, their D-line should be very good this season -- they'll slow some teams down. Just not ours. : )

I am all for Mara putting a halt to the roulette wheel of coaches, as long as the coach is lousy when to ball finds its slot. I don't really have a read on Daboll. He had the team over-performing a couple seasons ago, and he had a dreadful GM in place in the run up to it (and I am not sure the current GM is any good either). Hard to assess the coach when he's hamstrung like that. Having said all that, their D-line should be very good this season -- they'll slow some teams down. Just not ours. : )Their dline is going to be a big problem week 1. Dexter Lawrence is a monster in the middle. The Carter rookie is very, very quick on the edge and has moves. They have some dudes. I'd honestly be more worried about this game if Dart starts. Think he has a lot of potential and talent, but I fully expect to see Wilson week 1.

hopefully our history of losing to sorry @$$ giants teams is in the past now. good riddance.

It is totally on Daboll to create a positive culture within his own team. Players calling out the team as soft and questioning the team's effort is an extraordinary indictment of a coach who isn't getting it done. Again, I don't care if the players like him or not. He has done nothing worthwhile in the NFL and is very fortunate to still be a head coach. Nearly impossible to believe a coach is well liked whose team is being called soft by it's own personnel, questioning fellow teammates effort in games, and losing faith in their coach while winning 3 games total in 1 season.

Again, I get you will never be convinced but again what you posted isn't true.

Again, I get you will never be convinced but again what you posted isn't true.

Links and quotes seem to show otherwise but those blue glasses you're wearing sure are fashionable!

best of luck week 1