Daseal
04-01-2004, 07:58 PM
I'd say no thanks!
Taylor or Winslow are just too good to pass up. Sure, we get two low first round picks (the 2nd is practically a 2nd rounder) and a second rounder where we will find mediocre talent. I'd rather fill a hole for 10 years with an impact player!
Hail to the Redskins
04-01-2004, 08:13 PM
IF... I repeat .. IF that deal offer is true... and we get it instead of Detroit... for some reason I just don't see it... BUT
If so... I'd KEEP the 21st and 32nd picks and use the 21st on either Randy Starks, Will Smith, Vince Wilfork or Ben Troupe (whichever is still there)... and the 32nd on Jake Grove (or Troupe)
Grove is the best Center to come out in a WHILE and he would REALLY be the Jeff Bostic to this new group of HOGS. (I heard a rumor that Bugel really liked what he saw when scouting him.) It would allow us to let Larry Moore go... freeing up cap-space.
Starks, in my opinion, could be the steal of this draft. He is a STUD. Wilfork can plug an interior line all by himself a-la Gilbert Borwn and Ted Washington, only he is MUCH MUCH MUCH quicker than both. Will Smith has 10-15 sack potential and Troupe could be the Ben Coates, Keith Jackson. Jay Novacek compared to Winlsow being more Shockey... which makes me JUST as happy at the least.
Then in the second, we could take Boulware the LB and we are SET!
Of course... I just don't see the Pats giving all that up for one guy, seeing as how the team is set up to have no "superstars" .. just guys playing together, BUT .... I hope it works out....
Riggo44
04-01-2004, 08:47 PM
Hell yes we should take that. We can jus turn around, send those two first rounders right back to Detroit and get Kellen Winslow II. I'm HUGE on taylor, but two first rounders a second and a fourth would be a little much to pass up. I'd be happy just taking Taylor too.
No Kidding!
offiss
04-02-2004, 02:26 AM
Let's say we get a 2nd for Gardner. Is Trotter, the 2nd and maybe next year's 1st too much for the Lions' 1st this year and maybe another mid-to late round pick?
I am starting to get off the winslow band wagon as I talk about in a new thread, but if detroit would give up the #6 pick for trotter, gardner, and our #1 next year I would make that trade in a heartbeat, the problem is I think we would have to sweetin the pot a bit, probably 1 more pick might do it, and I say it would still be worth it, I just don't know if winslow will really fit in, charactor is the biggest factor when gibb's look's at a player, and that's the biggest problem when you look at winslow, Gibb's just doesn't want player's who stay out of serious trouble, he want's guy's who are real quality people, player's with big heart's on and off the field, the more I think about it the more I pull back from the thought of taking winslow. but I still say taylor is the man!
dieselhog
04-02-2004, 05:00 AM
Take the trade if it's there. It's not like we have spare picks cluttering up the war room. Besides, we can always sign Taylor when he becomes a free agent if 4 or 5 years time!! :laughing-