Re: 53-man Roster Predictions
 

2012 - tom compton (OT) - going to be a big part of 2015

2013 (8) - will compton - 1 tackle in 2013, 60 tackles in 2014
- xavier nixon - indy took him from us - 4 games, 1 start in both 2013 and 2014 (for indy)
- chase minnefield (did some stuff in 2014)

2014 (we had 8) - philip thomas, signed active on nov 1, had 27 tackles
- chris thompson - obviously has value
- chase minnefield - 7 game appearances 4 tackles
- robert thomas (DL) - signed to the active roster for 1 day, then back to PS

others did nothing


so that's the last 3-4 years and only looking at what they did here, but the % is much higher than i would have thought to play in real games and contribute.

i'd call is 4/24 for those 3 years, so 16% from the world's smallest and possibly not at all representative sample size. (also these were from the aug 31/sep 1 PS roster list, i didn't bother trying to look up in season transactions, but if you check kffl etc during the year, there are a LOT)

Re: 53-man Roster Predictions
 

[QUOTE=That Guy;1119328]2012 - tom compton (OT) - going to be a big part of 2015

2013 (8) - will compton - 1 tackle in 2013, 60 tackles in 2014
- xavier nixon - indy took him from us - 4 games, 1 start in both 2013 and 2014 (for indy)
- chase minnefield (did some stuff in 2014)

2014 (we had 8) - philip thomas, signed active on nov 1, had 27 tackles
- chris thompson - obviously has value
- chase minnefield - 7 game appearances 4 tackles
- robert thomas (DL) - signed to the active roster for 1 day, then back to PS

others did nothing


so that's the last 3-4 years and only looking at what they did here, but the % is much higher than i would have thought to play in real games and contribute.

i'd call is 4/24 for those 3 years, so 16% from the world's smallest and possibly not at all representative sample size. (also these were from the aug 31/sep 1 PS roster list, i didn't bother trying to look up in season transactions, but if you check kffl etc during the year, there are a LOT)[/QUOTE]
Thanks. I appreciate you digging in like that. My initial thinking was less than 5percent so that is more than I expected. Still I think it holds that by most practice squad players aren't going to make or break a team's roster.

Sent from my S6 Edge

Re: 53-man Roster Predictions
 

well, ryan clark was on NY's practice squad for 10+ weeks in 2002, lemar marshall was a PS player (ARI/PHI) that ended up starting 2-3 years here as a pretty good player.

obviously PS players are lower hit rates than high draft picks,, since they're (usually) UDFA's.

Re: 53-man Roster Predictions
 

[url=http://www.richmond.com/redskins-xtra/article_d154b062-557b-11e5-b2dc-a33b9fad3ef4.html]Redskins sign former Seahawks TE Anthony McCoy - Richmond Times-Dispatch: Redskins XTRA[/url]

New TE Anthony McCoy

Re: 53-man Roster Predictions
 

I don't see how anyone would not believe if RG3 stays a Redskin this year it isn't 100% Snyder's doing. Did everyone forget Gruden publicly throwing Robert under the bus last year? I figured Robert would be gone then. I would think the only thing he could do to change Jay's opinion of him is to light it up in 2015, and we know he hasn't done that. There is no upside to having RG3 on the team, anyone who has watched him on the sideline of the Jax game can
see he has mentally checked out. The circus around him isn't worth tolerating for a back up QB, especially for one who doesn't look like a team first guy anymore.

Re: 53-man Roster Predictions
 

[quote=Chico23231;1119348][url=http://www.richmond.com/redskins-xtra/article_d154b062-557b-11e5-b2dc-a33b9fad3ef4.html]Redskins sign former Seahawks TE Anthony McCoy - Richmond Times-Dispatch: Redskins XTRA[/url]

New TE Anthony McCoy[/quote]

2 achilles surgeries and like, 37 career receptions. mainly an in-line blocker, but still seems kinda... meh. I guess he's a guy and we needed a guy.

Re: 53-man Roster Predictions
 

[quote=That Guy;1119374]2 achilles surgeries and like, 37 career receptions. mainly an in-line blocker, but still seems kinda... meh. I guess he's a guy and we needed a guy.[/quote]

Basically best available guy...and better than our current option at 3rd TE

Re: 53-man Roster Predictions
 

[QUOTE=Chico23231;1119378]Basically best available guy...and better than our current option at 3rd TE[/QUOTE]
Wouldn't Detroit's guy have been better?

Sent from my S6 Edge

Re: 53-man Roster Predictions
 

Gruden on Rashad Ross:

“Yeah, a no-brainer,” Gruden said on Sunday afternoon when asked about Ross. “You talk about going out there and making plays, you know, and I’d be lying to you if I cut him. You’d say, ‘What about this guy? This guy made all kinds of plays and you cut him, you’re lying.’ So we talk about taking advantage of your opportunities, making plays, and we’re going to do what’s right by you, and the right thing was to keep him.”

I was pleased to see that he said this. He's right. Many people would have thought he and Scot were hypocrites if they had cut Ross. More importantly, by practicing what they preached they kept faith with Ross and the rest of the team.

Re: 53-man Roster Predictions
 

honestly the chance that ross has any real bearing on this season are really slim, and I doubt guys like DJ care about what happens to the #6 WR, but i'm sure the borderline players appreciate it.


meanwhile, updated practice squad list (we're up to 9 now):
LB Houston Bates, OT Takoby Cofield, DE Corey Crawford, CB Quinton Dunbar, LB Terrance Plummer, TE Je'Ron Hamm, RB Trey Williams, FB Ray Agnew, LB Ryan Delaire

Re: 53-man Roster Predictions
 

[QUOTE=That Guy;1119425]honestly the chance that ross has any real bearing on this season are really slim, and I doubt guys like DJ care about what happens to the #6 WR, but i'm sure the borderline players appreciate it.


meanwhile, updated practice squad list (we're up to 9 now):
LB Houston Bates, OT Takoby Cofield, DE Corey Crawford, CB Quinton Dunbar, LB Terrance Plummer, TE Je'Ron Hamm, RB Trey Williams, FB Ray Agnew, LB Ryan Delaire[/QUOTE]
I agree about Ross but I believe Garcon and Djax contracts both haveouts next year and its nice to have depth in Grant and Ross that let's us not be hogtied by one or both

Sent from my S6 Edge

Re: 53-man Roster Predictions
 

[quote=That Guy;1119425]honestly the chance that ross has any real bearing on this season are really slim, and I doubt guys like DJ care about what happens to the #6 WR, but i'm sure the borderline players appreciate it.[/quote]

I think Ross could help this year. First, he can return punts and KO's. I haven't seen anyone else who impressed me doing those things. Crowder is supposedly a good return man, but I haven't seen it yet.

If DJ gets hurt, then we'd be without a true burner to stretch the field if we didn't have Ross. Crowder is more quick than fast and the other two reserves are possession receivers.

Re: 53-man Roster Predictions
 

[quote=Buffalo Bob;1119356]I don't see how anyone would not believe if RG3 stays a Redskin this year it isn't 100% Snyder's doing. Did everyone forget Gruden publicly throwing Robert under the bus last year? I figured Robert would be gone then. I would think the only thing he could do to change Jay's opinion of him is to light it up in 2015, and we know he hasn't done that. There is no upside to having RG3 on the team, anyone who has watched him on the sideline of the Jax game can
see he has mentally checked out. The circus around him isn't worth tolerating for a back up QB, especially for one who doesn't look like a team first guy anymore.[/quote]

agree 100%
However he is so good at constantly reinforcing to everyone around him just how much of a "me first" kind of guy he is. I think most of the team can safely ignore him. If he has to stay, I just hope he "rides the pine" for the entire year."

Re: 53-man Roster Predictions
 

[URL="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/football-insider/wp/2015/09/07/draft-pick-evan-spencer-goes-unclaimed-reverts-to-redskins-ir-list/"]Draft pick Evan Spencer goes unclaimed, reverts to Redskins IR list[/URL]