Re: 2011 Redskins Free Agent Rumors and Reports Thread
 

So far the SKINS FO hide their moves well. The players we are going to bring in probably haven't even been talked about anywhere yet IMO.

Re: 2011 Redskins Free Agent Rumors and Reports Thread
 

[quote=NYCskinfan82;812023][B]So far the SKINS FO hide their moves well.[/B] The players we are going to bring in probably haven't even been talked about anywhere yet IMO.[/quote]

Very good point. Which is why I don't get why people get up in arms about any rumors about possible FAs, etc., etc.

Re: 2011 Redskins Free Agent Rumors and Reports Thread
 

[url=http://www.hogshaven.com/2011/7/22/2288455/browns-nose-tackle-ahtyba-rubin-possible-trade-target-for-redskins]Brown's Nose Tackle Ahtyba Rubin: Possible Trade Target for Redskins? - Hogs Haven[/url]

Saw this wanted to know what you think.

Re: 2011 Redskins Free Agent Rumors and Reports Thread
 

[quote=NYCskinfan82;812055][url=http://www.hogshaven.com/2011/7/22/2288455/browns-nose-tackle-ahtyba-rubin-possible-trade-target-for-redskins]Brown's Nose Tackle Ahtyba Rubin: Possible Trade Target for Redskins? - Hogs Haven[/url]

Saw this wanted to know what you think.[/quote]

I'd rather get Alan Branch without having to give up picks.

Re: 2011 Redskins Free Agent Rumors and Reports Thread
 

[quote=#56fanatic;811982]I really hope the front office (shanny) make resigning Moss a priority vs. signing Holmes. This would be the exact moves this franchise has made over the last 11 years. Letting your core guys leave to bring in a FA. We have to rid ourselves of these moves. We have young receivers and we need to develop them. Same as RB's, no need in bringing in a veteran. LB's, we have some young talent there. Lichensleiger (SP), Montgomery, seem to be ready to step up and play center. Let them compete for the job, Raymer has been good, but he may serve as a better back up at this point. We really need to develop our young talent.[/quote]

I'm really torn on this one.. On one hand Moss is one of my favorite players of recent Redskins teams and I'd hate to see him leave.. However he has some infuriating drops, is 32 and has battled leg injuries (although he's toughed them out) in recent years.

On the other hand, while Holmes seems to signal "same old Redskins" he's 26, a SB champ, proven clutch performer, great hands/speed combination and a top 15 WR in the league. If it wasn't for his off the field issues he would be as coveted of a FA receiver there ever has been on the open market.

If we made this move, everyone would be up in arms but I think this would turn out differently than previous FA forays..

How about both? Holmes, Hankerson, Moss, Armstrong, Kelly/Paul, Banks/Robinson? I wouldn't hate that.

Re: 2011 Redskins Free Agent Rumors and Reports Thread
 

[quote=Ruhskins;812059]I'd rather get Alan Branch without having to give up picks.[/quote]

You don't think they'd take Haynesworth straight up?!?

Re: 2011 Redskins Free Agent Rumors and Reports Thread
 

[quote=skinsfaninok;811954]I'm not too big on Holmes, solid player but not a dominant WR. I'd take him but not for big time $[/quote]

I think Moss's career numbers are better than Holmes. of course he's a little longer in the tooth.

Re: 2011 Redskins Free Agent Rumors and Reports Thread
 

[quote=Paintrain;812068]I'm really torn on this one.. On one hand Moss is one of my favorite players of recent Redskins teams and I'd hate to see him leave.. However he has some infuriating drops, is 32 and has battled leg injuries (although he's toughed them out) in recent years.

On the other hand, while Holmes seems to signal "same old Redskins" he's 26, a SB champ, proven clutch performer, great hands/speed combination and a top 15 WR in the league. If it wasn't for his off the field issues he would be as coveted of a FA receiver there ever has been on the open market.

If we made this move, everyone would be up in arms but I think this would turn out differently than previous FA forays..

How about both? Holmes, Hankerson, Moss, Armstrong, Kelly/Paul, Banks/Robinson? I wouldn't hate that.[/quote]

But if you had to sign only one WR, who would you pick? The idea of signing both to the squad is awesome, however I am not sure if we would have enough money to do that, along with necessities to fill other positions such as tackle (resign Brown), guard and nose-tackle.

Re: 2011 Redskins Free Agent Rumors and Reports Thread
 

[quote=Paintrain;812068]I'm really torn on this one.. On one hand Moss is one of my favorite players of recent Redskins teams and I'd hate to see him leave.. However he has some infuriating drops, is 32 and has battled leg injuries (although he's toughed them out) in recent years.

On the other hand, while Holmes seems to signal "same old Redskins" he's 26, a SB champ, proven clutch performer, great hands/speed combination and a top 15 WR in the league. If it wasn't for his off the field issues he would be as coveted of a FA receiver there ever has been on the open market.

If we made this move, everyone would be up in arms but I think this would turn out differently than previous FA forays..

How about both? Holmes, Hankerson, Moss, Armstrong, Kelly/Paul, Banks/Robinson? I wouldn't hate that.[/quote]Between Moss and Holmes it's easy: you sign Holmes. Doesn't matter that you're going to have to pay more, in free agency, its all about getting the most aggregate production out of the roster spot. Easiest FA mistake to make that results in deadcap is having the player that you can't find a role for, not having a player who is overpaid.

With that said, I agree with all parties who have suggested that a failed Santonio Holmes signing would be essentially committing the exact same error that made the franchise what it is today once again. They'd be taking a player who, in the last three seasons, has struggled twice with one career year, and a number of late game heroics that profile as garbage time TDs with the Redskins. So that can't be comforting.

But Holmes IS one of the best players on the market and he's not too old to justify his salary, and that goes far for NFL front offices, evaluation mistakes be damned.

Re: 2011 Redskins Free Agent Rumors and Reports Thread
 

[quote=GridIron26;812078]But if you had to sign only one WR, who would you pick? The idea of signing both to the squad is awesome, however I am not sure if we would have enough money to do that, along with necessities to fill other positions such as tackle (resign Brown), guard and nose-tackle.[/quote]

If it has to be one of them, give me Holmes. Younger and more productive.

Re: 2011 Redskins Free Agent Rumors and Reports Thread
 

[quote=NYCskinfan82;812055][url=http://www.hogshaven.com/2011/7/22/2288455/browns-nose-tackle-ahtyba-rubin-possible-trade-target-for-redskins]Brown's Nose Tackle Ahtyba Rubin: Possible Trade Target for Redskins? - Hogs Haven[/url]

Saw this wanted to know what you think.[/quote]

Rubin would be perfect but why would the Browns trade him?
He can easily play 4-3 DT.

[quote=GTripp0012;812086]But Holmes IS one of the best players on the market and he's not too old to justify his salary, and that goes far for NFL front offices, evaluation mistakes be damned.[/quote]I agree.

I'm one of Tana's biggest fans and I think we should re-sign him.
But, business is business.
I think Holmes is the better player and if we had a choice between Holmes and Tana I would take Holmes.
He's younger and I think he would be more productive then Tana as the focal point of our passing game.

Re: 2011 Redskins Free Agent Rumors and Reports Thread
 

Give me Moss over Holmes.

Holmes is, if I recall correctly, one strike away from a very lengthy suspension.

Plus, the point of drafting guys like Hankerson, Austin, even Kelly is to have those guys emerge as the leading WRs of the future. And that's not even mentioning Armstrong. I'd prefer we invest elsewhere

Re: 2011 Redskins Free Agent Rumors and Reports Thread
 

[quote=SmootSmack;812094]Give me Moss over Holmes.

Holmes is, if I recall correctly, one strike away from a very lengthy suspension.

Plus, the point of drafting guys like Hankerson, Austin, even Kelly is to have those guys emerge as the leading WRs of the future. And that's not even mentioning Armstrong. I'd prefer we invest elsewhere[/quote]I think the best chance for their(AA, Hank, Kelly) success and the best chance for the receiving corps to become a dynamic unit is to have a proven, reliable WR as the focal point.

Re: 2011 Redskins Free Agent Rumors and Reports Thread
 

[quote=30gut;812089]Rubin would be perfect but why would the Browns trade him?
He can easily play 4-3 DT.

[/quote]

Not always true. A lot of NT position players couldn't switch to the difference assignments of the 3 or 5 technique in a 4-3 scheme. A NT just eats space and takes on blockers. 4-3 DT would have a lot more responsibilities.

Basically think of Haynesworth. Well, Haynesworth is because he is worthless and lazy, some probably just don't have the skill set for it. If this guy can do shuttle runs without having to stop and take a crap in between, I say trade for the guy sight unseen otherwise...

Re: 2011 Redskins Free Agent Rumors and Reports Thread
 

i dont think the jets are letting holmes go, so i think picking between him or moss is kinda moot, BUT stranger things have happened...