Re: The Pro Days Thread
 

[quote=alaskaN8;902422]so i see alot of comparison between rg3 and vick. but how would you guys rate him agianst some of the younger quarterbacks in the league? like matt ryan, sam bradford, matt stafford or cam newton?[/quote]

I'd rate him pretty highly among that group, would put his potential at this point higher than all except maybe Cam.

Do you think RG3 has a stronger more accurate deep ball arm then Cam Newton?
I would say I think RG3 is more accurate but not sure on the bigger arm.

Re: The Pro Days Thread
 

If Luck has a great Pro Day today, I'll be on Cloud 9!

Even if he doesn't, I won't worry a bit about our future at QB. I sincerely believe that we can't lose by picking either Luck or RGIII.

Re: The Pro Days Thread
 

[quote=GMScud;902411]Don't get me wrong, I'm no fan of Merril Hoge, but apparently he watched 120 hours of film of RGIII and Luck. So say he split it 50/50. I find it hard to believe that 60 hours of RGIII only represents 5% of the info available of him.[/quote]

Even if it was, that still beats Joe fan watching some YouTube clips.

Re: The Pro Days Thread
 

[quote=alaskaN8;902422]so i see alot of comparison between rg3 and vick. but how would you guys rate him agianst some of the younger quarterbacks in the league? like matt ryan, sam bradford, matt stafford or cam newton?[/quote]

Most everything I have found dismisses the comparisons to Vick. He's at a better place in his development than Vick was at this point. I get uncomfortable with the comparison because I think it has more to do with the fact that they're both African-American than anything. It's a lazy parallel to draw.

Re: The Pro Days Thread
 

RG3 is far superior as a passer than Vick ever was or ever will be. I agree, it's a lazy comparison. Not fair to RG3 at all.

Re: The Pro Days Thread
 

[quote=KI Skins Fan;902452]If Luck has a great Pro Day today, I'll be on Cloud 9!

Even if he doesn't, I won't worry a bit about our future at QB. I sincerely believe that we can't lose by picking either Luck or RGIII.[/quote]
You can't, Luck is the best QB prospect most of us have ever seen (for the young guys).

I'm predicting a Matt Ryan impact from day 1.

Re: The Pro Days Thread
 

maybe it takes him a while to adust to the pros. I'd be shocked if he wasn't considered at least very good by the end of year 3 though. i think very good is the floor on this guy.

Re: The Pro Days Thread
 

Just curious as to how different a scripted pro day is different from a non scripted combine. How many hours did RGIII practice with his recievers on that scripted pro day? Can't wait to see Luck on his pro day to see if his is scripted as well, if so it is a waste of time and money to go through it because it is useless. JMHO.

Re: The Pro Days Thread
 

[quote=tmandoug1;902509]Just curious as to how different a scripted pro day is different from a non scripted combine. How many hours did RGIII practice with his recievers on that scripted pro day? Can't wait to see Luck on his pro day to see if his is scripted as well, if so it is a waste of time and money to go through it because it is useless. JMHO.[/quote]

Luck's will be scripted as well. All pro days are for QBs.

Re: The Pro Days Thread
 

Anyone know if Snyder and the Shanahan's are coming to see Luck today?

Re: The Pro Days Thread
 

[quote=SFREDSKIN;902517]Anyone know if Snyder and the Shanahan's are coming to see Luck today?[/quote]

Yes

Re: The Pro Days Thread
 

[quote=SFREDSKIN;902517]Anyone know if Snyder and the Shanahan's are coming to see Luck today?[/quote]I'm pretty sure I heard on Comcast SN that they flew straight from Waco, TX to CA after RGIII's workout.

Re: The Pro Days Thread
 

Random question that may be in the wrong thread/may have already been asked.

If the Colts decide they want Luck and are able to ink him to a contract before the draft, and the Skins allowed to start negotiating with RGIII right away?

Re: The Pro Days Thread
 

Thanks!

Re: The Pro Days Thread
 

[quote=FRPLG;902483]Most everything I have found dismisses the comparisons to Vick. He's at a better place in his development than Vick was at this point. I get uncomfortable with the comparison because I think it has more to do with the fact that they're both African-American than anything. It's a lazy parallel to draw.[/quote]

I've also come to the conclusion that it's not even an accurate comparison. RGIII doesn't have anything close to Vicks agility (no one does at the QB position). Sure he has similar straight line speed and good agility but it's not like the cut Vick makes to escape.