Re: Positional Rankings- No 'Skins in the top 6 at any position?
 

[quote=SantanaMan;325507]I don't take anything that Pete "On Crack" Prisco writes as serious, like c'mon FRED TAYLOR the 5th best RB in the league? Right now I don't even think he is the best RB on his team!
Ben Watson over Cooley?
Dawan Landry over Sean Taylor? Heck Dawan wasn't a starter till October! I'd take LaRon over Dawan right now.

I think the Skins should have Sean Taylor and Cooley there, possibly Samuels.[/quote]
I do agree Cooley, and Samuels deserve to be in the top six at their positions, but after the season Sean Taylor had last year he doesn't deserve to be in the top six. Based on LAST SEASON alone, I have the top 10 Safeties looking like this:
1.NYJ Kerry Rhodes 98Tck 5Sck 1FR 3FF 4Int 9PD
2.ARZ Adrian Wilson 82Tck 5Sck 2FR 4FF 4int 7PD
3.TEN Chris Hope 121Tck 1FR 5Int 10PD
4.BAL Dawan Landry 69Tck 3Sck 5Int 6PD
5.PHI Brian Dawkins 93Tck 1Sck 5FF 4Int 9PD
6.CLE Sean Jones 111Tck 0.5Sck 1FR 5Int 11PD
7.BAL Ed Reed 59Tck 1FR 1FF 5Int 4PD
8.NO Kevin Kaesviharn 63Tck 4Sck 1FF 6Int 2PD
9.MIN Dwight Smith 78Tck 1Sck 1FR 1FF 4Int 2PD
10.WAS Sean Taylor 111Tck 3FF 1Int 6PD (the homer in me taking over)

Re: Positional Rankings- No 'Skins in the top 6 at any position?
 

Not that I like the offensive picks by prisco but clark judge did the Defensive picks and they are pretty awful too. I don't mean to sound like a biased skins fan but the guy had some bad omissions and inclusions. I mean dawan landry, honestly, I would rather put Roy "Horse collar" Williams on that list not to mention Polamalu and a gang of others

Re: Positional Rankings- No 'Skins in the top 6 at any position?
 

really bad list.

Re: Positional Rankings- No 'Skins in the top 6 at any position?
 

I saw the title of the thread and I SWORE it said 'prostitutional rankings'...

Re: Positional Rankings- No 'Skins in the top 6 at any position?
 

Honestly with the exception of maybe a healthy Portis we don't have any top 5 elite talent players on the team.. Moss & Cooley are great no doubt, I'd say borderline top 5.. Portis, Moss, Cooley, Samuels, Thomas, Washington, Taylor, Springs are all top 10 at their position but top 5 is really elite..

Re: Positional Rankings- No 'Skins in the top 6 at any position?
 

How much of the hype for Dawan Landry comes from being on that defense? He plays with Reed, Mcallister and Rolle. If he didn't have that kind of talent around him where would he be?

Re: Positional Rankings- No 'Skins in the top 6 at any position?
 

It's hilarious that Kellen Winslow and Jeremy Shockey are both on the TE list and Cooley isn't.

Re: Positional Rankings- No 'Skins in the top 6 at any position?
 

Frank Gore at #3? :rofl:

Andre Johnson is better than Torry Holt and Marvin Harrison? :doh:

Kellen Winslow is better than Crumpler? :nono:

Kerry Rhodes? Who the f*ck is Kerry Rhodes? :doh:

This guy has no business writing football articles.

Re: Positional Rankings- No 'Skins in the top 6 at any position?
 

[quote=GhettoDogAllStars;326231]Frank Gore at #3? :rofl:

Andre Johnson is better than Torry Holt and Marvin Harrison? :doh:

Kellen Winslow is better than Crumpler? :nono:

Kerry Rhodes? Who the f*ck is Kerry Rhodes? :doh:

This guy has no business writing football articles.[/quote]
Kerry Rhodes is only one of the best young safeties in the league, probably better than Sean Taylor.

Re: Positional Rankings- No 'Skins in the top 6 at any position?
 

Until this team starts winning we will never get any respect. Right now we dont deserve any. Nobody expect maybe Cooley could be rated high at his postion. No one on the dling,LB or CB, or Safety. NO one on offense now since Portis is coming of injuries.

Re: Positional Rankings- No 'Skins in the top 6 at any position?
 

[quote=GhettoDogAllStars;326231]Frank Gore at #3? :rofl:

Andre Johnson is better than Torry Holt and Marvin Harrison? :doh:

Kellen Winslow is better than Crumpler? :nono:

Kerry Rhodes? Who the f*ck is Kerry Rhodes? :doh:

This guy has no business writing football articles.[/quote]

If you don't know who Kerry Rhodes is... Wow man.

Also, as much as I hate "The Soldier," he caught 90 balls in a miserable offense. He's pretty damn good.

Re: Positional Rankings- No 'Skins in the top 6 at any position?
 

I was okay with everything until I got to defense. Dawan Landry is the 4th best safety in the NFL?! Are you kidding me?!

Also, Fred Taylor is not the best 5th best running back in the league, but I could have lived with that.