Re: Zorn wants Collins back
 

[QUOTE=Mattyk72;423461]Dilfer would be nothing more than a #3/emergency type of QB for us. He would be a solid addition for his knowledge of the offense.[/QUOTE]


Exactly, that's what I was thinking in terms of him being, a 3rd QB at best.

Re: Zorn wants Collins back
 

I absolutely love Brunell, and have since he was at Jacksonville but one must wonder- how can we benefit from him now? IMO it would be better to let him go out and be a backup somewhere he is needed and bring in Dilfer as a #3. Collins has alot of knowledge as far as mechanics go and Dilfer knows the WCO. Given those two attributes plus a former QB coach running the team I see nothing but greatness for JC this year!!!

Re: Zorn wants Collins back
 

i do not want dilfer, not a single bit... he's trash weather he knows the offense or not man

Re: Zorn wants Collins back
 

No no no....we need Collins gone. The last thing we need is Campbell constantly looking over his shoulder.

Re: Zorn wants Collins back
 

[quote=Hog's Breath;423484]No no no....we need Collins gone. The last thing we need is Campbell constantly looking over his shoulder.[/quote]


If Cambell's psyche is that fragile he may want to think about another career. In this league you need 2 good QB's at least.

Re: Zorn wants Collins back
 

[quote=Hog's Breath;423484]No no no....we need Collins gone. The last thing we need is Campbell constantly looking over his shoulder.[/quote]

This is the NFL you are always looking over your shoulder at all positions, if you can't handle that your not going to make it in this league to begin with.

Why in the world would you want to see one hell of a solid backup, that even turned into a really good starter for us last season,not here?

This is the business of football at the highest level you HAVE to have proven depth at your QB position I would argue this is the most important backup role more than any other position on the team. I think we found that out in the last four games of last season. Its not a luxury it's a necessity.

Re: Zorn wants Collins back
 

Collins is like a hot girl that we keep on the side. ;) - Todays smiley face brought to you by Om, the creepy 47 year old smiley face man.

Re: Zorn wants Collins back
 

[QUOTE=Soup's Uncle;423349]trent dilfer is garbage though. didn't he get some PT this year for the 9'errs who play WCO and he was god awful?[/QUOTE] Agree but to be fair to Dilfer it was pretty much the hole team that sucked.

Re: Zorn wants Collins back
 

[QUOTE=Soup's Uncle;423349]trent dilfer is garbage though. didn't he get some PT this year for the 9'errs who play WCO and he was god awful?[/QUOTE]

no just the niners junk line was awful..they went through like 4 qb's this year due to injuries.

Re: Zorn wants Collins back
 

I would suggest that perhaps Zorn doesn't especially want Collins back with the team. Even the staunchest defenders of Collins would say that he is a system guy, and we are going to a new system.

Zorn probably realizes that there are a number of fans who love what Collins did for this team last year, and if he makes no effort to re-sign Todd, he will be excoriated by the fans and pundits. So he says he wants him here, but makes no strong effort to keep him. That way it's a financial issue, and he can't be raked over the coals.

Re: Zorn wants Collins back
 

[QUOTE=Mattyk72;423461]Dilfer would be nothing more than a #3/emergency type of QB for us. He would be a solid addition for his knowledge of the offense.[/QUOTE]


Then why not just give Dilfer a coaching role?

Re: Zorn wants Collins back
 

[QUOTE=skinsnut;423573]Then why not just give Dilfer a coaching role?[/QUOTE]

I'm a little confused in general why we would need another 'mentor' for Campbell if Dilfer was to fulfill that role. Isn't that why we brought a guy named ZORN to Washington?

Re: Zorn wants Collins back
 

[QUOTE=CPAlltheWay012;423580]I'm a little confused in general why we would need another 'mentor' for Campbell if Dilfer was to fulfill that role. Isn't that why we brought a guy named ZORN to Washington?[/QUOTE]

Not really.. A coach can only do so much, especially a head coach.. A veteran QB, mentor if you will, can spend time after practice or film time during camp or just an extra ear on the sidelines to talk thru things.. A head coach has so many other responsibilities he's got to handle and there are only so many hours he can dedicate to one player.

Re: Zorn wants Collins back
 

[quote=CPAlltheWay012;423580]I'm a little confused in general why we would need another 'mentor' for Campbell if Dilfer was to fulfill that role. Isn't that why we brought a guy named ZORN to Washington?[/quote]

the same way collins was helping campbell learn saunders offense.

Re: Zorn wants Collins back
 

Will Collins be as effective in another offense as he was Al Saunders? I'm for holding on to him or Brunell but not both and perhaps drafting a late round QB.