Re: The Dirtbags
 

what was the deciding factor is that d-line man back in those days were so small, 270 to 280lbs, and when the hoggs for example, jacoby was the biggest and he was 300 or 310. when the dline man started getting bigger the oline man had to adjust to make it in the NFL. the only team I see that is the exception to that rule is the broncos and maybe KC. They use alot of stretch plays that uses the lines athletic ability rather than brute strength. That wont fly in the NFC east. you know it and I know it. thats why these teams are getting LBs that can run like DBs. They can cover alot of ground. and these safeties now are huge. Taylor is LB size and runs like a corner. The whole NFL is getting bigger. But you have got to have speed in todays NFL defenses.

Re: The Dirtbags
 

I for one do think it's retarded that there is an option to have a cowboys helmet for an avatar on this site.

I don't come here to trash talk with the likes of you. I come here to discuss with fellow Redskins fans, KNOWLEDGABLE FANS. If you eliminated all grabbing of any kind from the game, like you're suggesting, scores would be 3-0, 7-3, 6-3 every single game in every single week. You know nothing.

Re: The Dirtbags
 

i havn't even said anything about all the grabbing. I think there are foolish holding penalties called in the NFL. But you have to call the obvious ones. They are trying to eliminate the holding and contact with the DBs to increase scoring, dont know if that has worked yet haven't read any stats to support it. There is now way you can try and stop holding and pulling down, there would be a penalty on every play if they did call the holding and pulling down that goes on. I think they do a pretty decent job for what they have to deal with on the field. I wouldn't want to be out there with 300lb+ line man running at me, linebackers running over me to get to the ball. QBs throwing darts at my head to hit the receiver across the middle. Oh, sorry you aren't talking to #56 fanatic are you, you talking to DALLAS guy right? if your talking to me, then refer to the above.

Re: The Dirtbags
 

[QUOTE=#56fanatic]i havn't even said anything about all the grabbing. I think there are foolish holding penalties called in the NFL. But you have to call the obvious ones. They are trying to eliminate the holding and contact with the DBs to increase scoring, dont know if that has worked yet haven't read any stats to support it. There is now way you can try and stop holding and pulling down, there would be a penalty on every play if they did call the holding and pulling down that goes on. I think they do a pretty decent job for what they have to deal with on the field. I wouldn't want to be out there with 300lb+ line man running at me, linebackers running over me to get to the ball. QBs throwing darts at my head to hit the receiver across the middle. Oh, sorry you aren't talking to #56 fanatic are you, you talking to DALLAS guy right? if your talking to me, then refer to the above.[/QUOTE]

Sorry I should have quoted him. Yes, I was talking to 5Rings.

Re: The Dirtbags
 

[ If you eliminated all grabbing of any kind from the game, like you're suggesting, scores would be 3-0, 7-3, 6-3 every single game in every single week. You know nothing.[/QUOTE]

When I watch a Football game, I love to focus on what I consider to be the heart of the Sport and that is line play.

To me there is nothing like watching a pulling Guard bend a Blitzer in half with a well angled and well timed block. When a lineman holds - and here I am talking about pulling a D lineman down or sideways after the o lineman has been beat, I am not talking about grabbing his pads over his chet an locking the man down tight - all it means is that he has been beat. How many holding calls negate long runs and scoring plays because an O lineman got beat and held his opponent? Denver is constantly drafting and TEACHING O linemen how to play in space and move their feet while it seems most everybody else just draft miniature Apt buildings and teaches them how to hold and not get caught.

Re: The Dirtbags
 

[QUOTE=5RINGS]If you eliminated all grabbing of any kind from the game, like you're suggesting, scores would be 3-0, 7-3, 6-3 every single game in every single week. You know nothing.

When I watch a Football game, I love to focus on what I consider to be the heart of the Sport and that is line play.

To me there is nothing like watching a pulling Guard bend a Blitzer in half with a well angled and well timed block. When a lineman holds - and here I am talking about pulling a D lineman down or sideways after the o lineman has been beat, I am not talking about grabbing his pads over his chet an locking the man down tight - all it means is that he has been beat. How many holding calls negate long runs and scoring plays because an O lineman got beat and held his opponent? Denver is constantly drafting and TEACHING O linemen how to play in space and move their feet while it seems most everybody else just draft miniature Apt buildings and teaches them how to hold and not get caught.[/QUOTE]

I'm guessing you're the kind of guy that thought the NHL shouldn't make any rule changes to open up the offense? The NFL would go south in a hurry if zebras were painting the grass yellow on every other play while scrutinizing holding calls. It's just not practical.

Re: The Dirtbags
 

[QUOTE=Schneed10]I'm guessing you're the kind of guy that thought the NHL shouldn't make any rule changes to open up the offense? The NFL would go south in a hurry if zebras were painting the grass yellow on every other play while scrutinizing holding calls. It's just not practical.[/QUOTE]

Au Contraire, I am exactly the kind of guy who just wanted the NHL to call what was ALREADY in the rule book!!! When they stopped calling the stick fouls the game got plodding and low scoring. Guys with no talent got by through hooking and holding. They made a real effort to change that mentality and so far it seems like the players have stopped all the stick fouls - or at least accepted that they will be called for it.

I think the same would happen in the NFL if linemen were held accountable for holding infractions, unless you think hockey players are somehow smarter than Football players and O Lineman couldn't figure out how to change their style of play.

Re: The Dirtbags
 

Hey. Easy now on 5 rings. He was just making a comment about holding. He wasn't trashing the Skins. He has been on here before and has been classy and made some astute observations. So take it easy.
The point I was making about 8 fingers isn't about holding. It's about the god awful casts that he has to wear, which don't look too comfortable AND that a broken thumb MUST be friggin' painful. And he has 2!! I imagine it limits his full ability in some way. Not for holding.... which EVERYONE does from time to time.

Re: The Dirtbags
 

[QUOTE=dblanch66]Quietly, our offensive line is having a strong beginning in these games. Granted they have given up some sacks and CP only ran for 90 yards last week (Betts had like, 34yds) but it must be taken into consideration that Jansen is playing with 8 FINGERS! I don't think Denver has faced an O line as good as ours yet. KC was missing Roaf and Jacksonville doesn't boast our talent. This will be the key to Sunday's game: How well the O line protects MB and opens holes for CP and Ladell will decide the game. As the season progresses and the line continues to jell, look out.[/QUOTE]

I have to disagree with this one. I would have thought that by the fourth game of the season, Samuels, Dockery, Rabach, Thomas, and Jansen would have established themselves as among the top five offensive lines in the league. Unfortunately, this is not the case. Portis has had 3.6 and 3.0 yard per carry averages against the Cowboys and Seahawks, respectively. As a tandem, Portis and Betts have yet to crack the 4 yard per carry average this season. Plus, this line has allowed 10 sacks over three games.

While Jansen's broken thumbs certainly are a hinderance, I don't think anyone would rationally try to argue that the line would be significantly improved with just two more operable digits for Jansen to work with.

Our undefeated start does tend to gloss over things over a bit, but not since the second half against Chicago has this line really taken over a game. For this team to continue it's unbeaten streak, the line play must get better. That means better pass protection, and more holes for Portis and Betts to go through. With more playing time and healthy starters, this O-line can be among the top five, but they're not quite there yet.

Re: The Dirtbags
 

[QUOTE=5RINGS]Jansen is playing with 8 FINGERS!

Uh, yeah...


What the hell does an OLineman need fingers for? To get holding penalties? I think they should put them in fingerless gloves and be done with it. There is FAR too much holding in the league, it is hurting the game.[/QUOTE]

if they did that, then passing would be worthless, running too... Dlines would become even more important and offenses would be toned down (And that's really bad for ratings), so i never think that'll happen. Old school football used closed fist blocking on olines i believe.... total slugfests.

Re: The Dirtbags
 

[QUOTE=#56fanatic]what are you doing showing your face on a Redskins website. The helmut NOT having a star on it should send a clue. Dont even talk trash on this site. You are not welcomed here. I didn't see any of those Dallas d-lineman getting past Jansen. Man, Jansen could be on one crutch and still hold off your team. get real, find a Dallas site![/QUOTE]

um, he wasn't trolling... even roids fans are allowed opinions ;)

Re: The Dirtbags
 

dblanche66, and That Guy,

thanks for the back up. This site has been a good place to talk football and NFC East Football. I do go to cowboys sites as well, but sometimes you gotta admit seeing GOOO COWBOYS!!!!! about 50 times gets old. I understand that people will at first wonder WTF! go to a Cowboys site, but I think most have been very open and reasonable once the first dagger has been thrown.

Re: The Dirtbags
 

[QUOTE=#56fanatic]what are you doing showing your face on a Redskins website. The helmut NOT having a star on it should send a clue. Dont even talk trash on this site. You are not welcomed here. I didn't see any of those Dallas d-lineman getting past Jansen. Man, Jansen could be on one crutch and still hold off your team. get real, find a Dallas site![/QUOTE]


Thats a mighty strong opion for someone that just joined this site this month...After 5RINGS joined actually.

Theres no need to be a jerk. Having fans of other teams make sites like this better because it keeps everyone in check. As it is theres plenty of opinion that are made with the 'red glasses' on, and that takes away from an educated discussion way more than an opinion of a fan from another team.

Re: The Dirtbags
 

Fans from other teams are always welcome here, looks like we could use a refresher on the [url="http://www.thewarpath.net/announcement.php?f=2"]site guidelines[/url], a little light reading as you're killing those last few hours at work on a Friday!

Re: The Dirtbags
 

[QUOTE=Mattyk72]Fans from other teams are always welcome here, looks like we could use a refresher on the [url="http://www.thewarpath.net/announcement.php?f=2"]site guidelines[/url], a little light reading as you're killing those last few hours at work on a Friday![/QUOTE]

are you implying that I am not doing work at work right now...lol