What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

Out of all the RB in minicamp, who do you think will make the roster, where at on roster, and why? We have Portis, Betts, Cartwright, Alridge, Dorsey, and Mason competing to be on the team roster. Obviously Portis is probably a lock at the #1 slot, but from there it is not 100% certain in my book. What do you think is in the best interest for the Redskins at the RB positions?

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

1. Portis
2. Betts
3. Cartwright

Same as last year.

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

[quote=Mattyk72;555389]1. Portis
2. Betts
3. Cartwright

Same as last year.[/quote]

Couldn't agree more! Mason has nice wiggle...but can't pick up the bltiz. These three are the best available. Unless that "speed back" Aldridge proves to be a worthy scat-back. Then he can replace Cartwright.

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

[quote=Mattyk72;555389]1. Portis
2. Betts
3. Cartwright

Same as last year.[/quote]

Take it to the bank.

Portis-obviously. Betts-too much money tied up. Cartwright-Special teams + player and returner. No one else even has a shot in any way.

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

[quote=Mattyk72;555389]1. Portis
2. Betts
3. Cartwright

Same as last year.[/quote]

I think this is right; however Rock could be at greater risk than last season.

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

Portis and Betts are locks. Cartwright, i'm not so sure about. He has teams value, yes, but he's old and we never ever ever want to see him take a snap at RB.

I dont think Mason has a chance, but i wouldnt be surprised if Dorsey or Aldridge replaced Cartwright as a 3rd RB/ST player. Guys like Tryon, Barnes and some of the receivers we've been looking at could replace some of Cartwrights duties on special teams. More likely than not, we go with Cartwright another year, but he's going to have to fight really hard to keep his job.

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

[quote=BigHairedAristocrat;555415]Portis and Betts are locks. Cartwright, i'm not so sure about. He has teams value, yes, but he's old and we never ever ever want to see him take a snap at RB.

I dont think Mason has a chance, but i wouldnt be surprised if Dorsey or Aldridge replaced Cartwright as a 3rd RB/ST player. Guys like Tryon, Barnes and some of the receivers we've been looking at could replace some of Cartwrights duties on special teams. More likely than not, we go with Cartwright another year, but he's going to have to fight really hard to keep his job.[/quote]

I think this [B]might[/B] be the year for Cartwright to go. [B]If [/B]that happens I'm betting Aldridge is #3 on the depth chart. [B]If[/B] he leaves his locker room presence will be missed.

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

Rock seems to be on the block every year with the fans. I doubt he's going anywhere.

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

[quote=Mattyk72;555458]Rock seems to be on the block every year with the fans. I doubt he's going anywhere.[/quote]

He's part of the fan's "All-Cut" team...
- Rock
- ARE
- Rabach
- Jensen
- Campbell
- Sellers (2008 offseason)

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

[quote=Ruhskins;555462]He's part of the fan's "All-Cut" team...
- Rock
- ARE
- Rabach
- Jensen
- Campbell
- Sellers (2008 offseason)[/quote]

lol, you forgot Thrash tho.

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

[quote=NM Redskin;555485]lol, you forgot Thrash tho.[/quote]
and jansen

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

anyways, if anybody is going to replace someone on that lineup of 3, I'll say Alridge

they've had him doing returns, lining up as a wideout, and running the rock - versatility that Rock can't provide, or at least hasn't been asked to

a lot of people in Denver were excited about Alridge before his injury and I think that this year or next he could easily be a number 3 back anywhere and a number 2 on many teams

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

1. Portis
2. Betts
3. Alridge (also returning kicks)

There. I said it. I love Rock but sooner or later he'll go. I predict sooner. I believe that the FO picked up two speed burners early in the offseason for a reason.

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

[quote=Lotus;555508]1. Portis
2. Betts
3. Alridge (also returning kicks)

There. I said it. I love Rock but sooner or later he'll go. I predict sooner. I believe that the FO picked up two speed burners early in the offseason for a reason.[/quote]

I agree. I know we go through this every year with Rock, but if one of these guys can push him at all, I believe they'll let him go. At least I think that's what they are really trying to do. Rock is good, but I really think they're trying to add some speed.

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

[quote=tryfuhl;555487]and jansen[/quote]

and Betts

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

1. Portis
2. Betts
3. Alridge (also returning kicks)

I have a feeling they are not in love with Rock. Seems like they went out of the way to bring in competition.

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

[quote=tryfuhl;555488]anyways, if anybody is going to replace someone on that lineup of 3, I'll say Alridge

they've had him doing returns, lining up as a wideout, and running the rock - versatility that Rock can't provide, or at least hasn't been asked to

a lot of people in Denver were excited about Alridge before his injury and I think that this year or next he could easily be a number 3 back anywhere and a number 2 on many teams[/quote]


It was also brought up that the rules have changed in regards to how KR's are blocked which will put a damper on players like Rock who rely on holes being made and hitting them fast and decleating opponants. Now it seems everyone may be looking for the speed guy who can get up field quicker and possibly make opponants miss a few tackles.

I think this yr Rock is let go for a more faster/shiftier back who can do all the jobs, KR/PR/RB/WR.

Now do I see Betts going anywhere....no. but if Zorn is looking to get younger or to have a younger guy for Portis to mold for our future then I see him as gone.

Portis
Mason (under dog man crush)
Aldridge (complete small package)
Dorsey (Practice squad)

I see the future of the RB's. Then I realized I was day dreaming;

Portis
Betts
Aldridge
Dorsey....maybe practice squad. Depends on how well he does.

I don't think Mason can go on practic squad again since he was on a roster last yr. I think he gets let go ....again.

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

Orakpo has a really fast 40 time. I know it would never happen but I would love too see him get the rock right up the middle for short yardage plays. I am sure if he can bench 530pd he probably wont fumble.

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

[quote=SBXVII;555583]It was also brought up that the rules have changed in regards to how KR's are blocked which will put a damper on players like Rock who rely on holes being made and hitting them fast and decleating opponants. Now it seems everyone may be looking for the speed guy who can get up field quicker and possibly make opponants miss a few tackles.

I think this yr Rock is let go for a more faster/shiftier back who can do all the jobs, KR/PR/RB/WR.
[/quote]

Definitely agree. I love that Rock never leaves us in a bad position and that he isn't afraid, but sometimes you see a hole and it's like damn man, why didn't you go for that instead of just hitting the 2 guys that you're one blocker is trying to hold back?

And the rule, I don't even know why that exists, it's ridiculous. If someone is a couple yards out is that no longer a wedge? no 3 man? what about 2 up front, 2 behind.. or 2 groups of 2 side by side with a gap in the middle?

did we really lose many (or any) players to a 3 man wedge last year in the NFL?

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

agreed its gonna be the same as last year

1. Portis
2. Betts (dont HATE EM, but hes so damn tradeable... i want a dif #2)
3. Cartwright

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

[quote=Skins4L;555916]agreed its gonna be the same as last year

1. Portis
2. Betts (dont HATE EM, but hes so damn tradeable... i want a dif #2)
3. Cartwright[/quote]

I wouldn't call Betts tradeable at this point. Nobody's seen anything of him for 2 years.

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

maybe your right. lol he might not be tradeable at all

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

[quote=tryfuhl;555918]I wouldn't call Betts tradeable at this point. Nobody's seen anything of him for 2 years.[/quote]

I think if Betts was able to spell Portis more often and shine a little he might have some trade value, but Portis doesn't come out unless he's extremely exhausted or hurt. I honestly don't think we would get a very high pick for him either. If he was all that great people would have been lining up to sign him when he was available. If I remember correctly he had no nibbles and actually got less then what he thought he would get.

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

Portis
alridge
Mason

Betts and rock get cut

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

1. Portis
2. Betts
3. Aldridge (PR & KR)

It's pretty obvious from what they bought in the FO and offensive staff want a Sproles like player on the roster, which Rock is not. The fact that Aldridge was endorsed by Shanahan probably endears him more to the FO than the fact Rock is a holdover from previous regimes.

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

[quote=Skins4L;555916]agreed its gonna be the same as last year

1. Portis
2. Betts (dont HATE EM, but hes so damn tradeable... i want a dif #2)
3. Cartwright[/quote]

We could get a 5th round pick AT BEST for Betts. He's not elite in anything he does, he'll be 30 this year and is often injured.

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

[quote=KingRaloIV;556073]Portis
alridge
Mason

Betts and rock get cut[/quote]

Even if Alridge and Mason outperformed in camp I doubt that Betts would get cut.

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

[quote=Ruhskins;555462]He's part of the fan's "All-Cut" team...
- Rock
- ARE
- Rabach
- Jensen
- Campbell
- Sellers (2008 offseason)[/quote]

And Betts...lol

Re: What RB will make the roster, where at on roster, and why?
 

Portis
Betts
Brian Mitchell (all time great returner)(it's a tough market and he's gonna need a job)