Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

Go vote on main page of [URL="http://www.dcprosportsreport.com"][B]DC Pro Sports Report[/B][/URL]

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

Close between big Mike and Colt.

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

Mike Williams

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

This was a pretty tough one. I vote Justin Tryon. With just taking Barnes in the third round, you have to think they will keep him. Can we honestly say Tryon is better than Westbrook.

The team invested too much in Devin Thomas. I would think, even as poor as he has been, he will stick for at least one more season. Mike Williams seems to think he will be on the field on 9/13 and indications are he will.

That leaves Brennan. I just don't see the Redskins choosing Daniel over Brennan, who has been in the system for a full year.

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

Thomas has at least shown some promise and improvement in camp, he probably doesn't deserve to be on the list.

Tryon will stick one more year, he's got more upside than Westbrook.

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

[quote=Mattyk72;580212]Close between big Mike and Colt.[/quote]

Jason Reid thinks the Skins have invested too much into Big Mike to let him go. Of those listed, i think Brennan is the most in trouble.

Unfortunately, I think we're going to be in a situation again this year, where we place several backup OL on our practice squad and they get signed to another teams active roster. As of right now, I think our backup OL will consist of Bridges (T/G), Mike Williams(T), Rinehart(G), and Montgommery(G/C). Investment in MW aside, who would our second backup OT be? Certainly not Rinehart or Montgommery. I wish there was a way to keep Edwin Williams, but it just doesnt look like its in the cards.

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

I don't even think it's close. Brennan by a mile. The others all have too much invested in them to be let go right now.

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

[quote=FRPLG;580229]I don't even think it's close. Brennan by a mile. The others all have too much invested in them to be let go right now.[/quote]Totally agree. Colt will be playing for his career as a Redskin against NE Friday night. If he continues to play indisciplined and forces balls that result in a pick or two, he may well be gone. He needs a good performance more than any player on the roster IMO.

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

Rock is in danger me thinks.

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

One player who I think is safe is Reed Doughty, he has been outstanding and Kareem Moore hasn't so far. I hope to keep Moore as I like him, but would not be surprised if he was let go in a shocker move. Renaldo Wynn is the other.

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

[quote=SFREDSKIN;580241]One player who I think is safe is Reed Doughty, he has been outstanding and Kareem Moore hasn't so far. I hope to keep Moore as I like him, but would not be surprised if he was let go in a shocker move. Renaldo Wynn is the other.[/quote]

I think they'll keep both Doughty and Moore

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

Suisam

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

Not to dig up the past but, where are all of those that were calling for JCs head and praying for Colt to start by the 4th game??

I like his as a person, but he is gone.

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

[quote=BigHairedAristocrat;580219]Jason Reid thinks the Skins have invested too much into Big Mike to let him go. Of those listed, i think Brennan is the most in trouble.
[/quote]

I'm trying to think of what we've invested in him other than just an opportunity and welcoming; we pretty much did it as a favor to Dockery.

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

I voted M. Williams.. Even though he's like 29 years old and a vet, but is he not eligible for PS? I don't think he has ever been on one before, if so which should makes him to be eligible for it? It might not be an ideal and will be sort of embarrassing for him but I think this would be the best situation for both Redskins and him?

I just don't think we should risk it and sign E. Williams to PS, since Bugel believes that he's doing good.. We lost Crummey to Bengal, who was going to be an replacement for one of our men.. We cannot continue to lose our replacements..

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

I said Big Mike because of all of the reports out of camp which said that he could not block anyone at all. No one expected him to be Jonathan Ogden out of the blocks but if you can't really block anyone, you are of no use. Further, I do not understand the comments about having too much invested in him. He came in out of nowhere for a minimal salary; it's not like we spent a lot of money or training effort on him, as we have with Colt, Devin, or Tryon.

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

[quote=GridIron26;580271]I voted M. Williams.. Even though he's like 29 years old and a vet, but is he not eligible for PS? I don't think he has ever been on one before, if so which should makes him to be eligible for it? It might not be an ideal and will be sort of embarrassing for him but I think this would be the best situation for both Redskins and him?

I just don't think we should risk it and sign E. Williams to PS, since Bugel believes that he's doing good.. We lost Crummey to Bengal, who was going to be an replacement for one of our men.. We cannot continue to lose our replacements..[/quote]

He's not eligible. He was like a 3 and a half year starter for the Bills

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

:pffff: Mike Williams, he is the only "non Vinny draft pick".

On another note, I cannot believe how many people actully think that Chase Daniel is going to win a roster spot over PJ5. It is just laughable. Chase Daniel had 1 ok performance this preseason. PJ5 had 2 last preseason. Not to mention the fact that he did not play that poorly against the Ravens considering that he was playing with no oline help. This last game he was doing well before the pick. Their are 2 preseason games left we'll see. If PJ5 gets cut, I will change my Avatar. :silly:

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

[quote=tryfuhl;580264]I'm trying to think of what we've invested in him other than just an opportunity and welcoming; we pretty much did it as a favor to Dockery.[/quote]

Certainly not $$, he's got no bonus so he can be gone like a fart in the wind.

I read what Reid said and I'm not buying that he's sure to make the team at all.

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

Mike Williams.

You really don't lose anything if you cut him. I don't think he's impressed Buges. He has raved about Montgomery, E.Williams, and Rinehart, but has said very little about Mike.

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

[quote=SmootSmack;580276]He's not eligible. He was like a 3 and a half year starter for the Bills[/quote]

Oh I see.. I thought that since he never was on PS, then he would be.. Well, tough luck for Mike I guess.. However, we definitely need to give him credit, he lost lot of weight and worked hard.. Like someone said in another thread, maybe we could put him on PUP until midseason and see if we would need a back up T or not..

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

[quote=Trample the Elderly;580300]Mike Williams.

You really don't lose anything if you cut him. I don't think he's impressed Buges. He has raved about Montgomery, E.Williams, and Rinehart, but has said very little about Mike.[/quote]

The one thing that they can't take away from Mike Williams is his determination, we know he had the skill a few years ago and who's to say that he can't get it back if he's healthy. How about Devin Clark? What kind of camp has he had? Anyone know?

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

big mike is in trouble. too injury prone for me.

Re: Pimp the poll: Which player is in biggest roster trouble
 

[quote=SFREDSKIN;580302]The one thing that they can't take away from Mike Williams is his determination, we know he had the skill a few years ago and who's to say that he can't get it back if he's healthy. How about Devin Clark? What kind of camp has he had? Anyone know?[/quote]

He wasn't on the pole. Yeah, they haven't said much about him at all.