Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

He's got to have some trade value. Doubt he gets straight up released.

[url=http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2011/01/05/bud-adams-chooses-jeff-fisher-over-vince-young/]Bud Adams chooses Jeff Fisher over Vince Young | ProFootballTalk[/url]

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

No thanks!!

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

No one will trade much for a player that's going to be released. I will be shocked if they get anything better than a 5th rounder.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

Someone will give up a pick for him...just want him to stay away from DC.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

2nd time someone else and I have been making thread about the same time.. whoops

guess someone was able to talk some sense into Adams, not that I think that Vince Young can't be a good QB

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

I like Fisher a lot, but I think players are starting to tune him out. After so many years it's inevitable. I would have moved him out, but with Heimerdinger's cancer there's no obvious successor. I think if the threat of a lockout weren't there, Adams may have gone in a different direction

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

AH for Young. Why not?

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

I'll pass.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

I would give a ham sandwich for Haynesworth!!!! And I was one who thought he would still contribute something after the off-season antics.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

Damn 2 Big long time no see...

I would give VY a chance [U][SIZE=6]ONLY[/SIZE] [/U]if we can get him in FA for chump change... Shanny made Plummer a winner, and Young has some rare talents.. He played great in a couple games this year especially in Dallas.

[url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vince_Young]Vince Young - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia[/url]

[url=http://www.nfl.com/players/vinceyoung/profile?id=YOU617196]Vince Young, QB for the Tennessee Titans at NFL.com[/url]

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

Yeah, he has some growing up to do, but he's a young QB with some upside. Is he better than anything we have now? I say yes.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

It is funny as Jake Plummer is exactly what I see when I see VY! I personally don't want him but if cheap and a stop gap till we can load up on other talent elsewhere... do it! He was a starter and with Sexy Rexy we would have 1 whole starter. We could go 8-8 with either but with 3 new starters in other positions. The 3 starters would be from the draft when we trade down... slowly get better so we can stay good for a while! Damn I miss the winning Redskin days! My kids don't think the Redskins have ever won...till they watch the super bowls memories on NFL Network!

I read everything on this site all the time...I just don't always have the time to write.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

He is a complete idiot...no thanks. Give me a qb who can think and read defensive coverages any day over a great "athlete"

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

[quote=2BIG2BSKINNY;775522]It is funny as Jake Plummer is exactly what I see when I see VY! I personally don't want him but if cheap and a stop gap till we can load up on other talent elsewhere... do it! He was a starter and with Sexy Rexy we would have 1 whole starter. We could go 8-8 with either but with 3 new starters in other positions. The 3 starters would be from the draft when we trade down... slowly get better so we can stay good for a while! Damn I miss the winning Redskin days! My kids don't think the Redskins have ever won...till they watch the super bowls memories on NFL Network!

I read everything on this site all the time...I just don't always have the time to write.[/quote]

I'm 24 so I hav'nt seen much winning in my life either!!! It's time for a change

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

[quote=DM72;775520]Yeah, he has some growing up to do, but he's a young QB with some upside. Is he better than anything we have now? I say yes.[/quote]

In this case would we rather draft say a Cam Newton instead?

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

I don't want VY on this team. I don't want to call VY a head case, but he's got issues that aren't solved that easily. We've already seen what happens when you have a head case on the roster, and Shanny has shown he wants guys that are all about the team. I don't think VY fits that mold. VY has the potential to be a headcase down the road.

And this sucks from a draft standpoint because the Titans are ahead of us in the pecking order, and now they're in the market for a quarterback.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

how about trade Mcnabb to Tennessee! get a forth rounder for him...then we can do many things in our posistion. Could be an opportunity to get a veteran QB to a team that may only have 1 year for a coach to save his job. (Jeff Fisher)

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

The only problem I see with taking a chance on Vince Young is that if Jeff Fisher can't tolerate Young on his team then I can't imagine Shanny and Young getting along.

Otherwise, what the heck, go for it! Young has talent. If the Titans would like to swap Young for Haynesworth, as was suggested above, so much the better. Then, we might have a better chance of trading McNabb for a draft pick and we wouldn't need to use a draft pick on a QB. Then, as 2Big suggested, trade down in the draft and load up on rookie talent.

- Add Young
- Dump Haynesworth
- Trade McNabb for a draft pick
- Sign a couple of good FA's
- Trade down in the first round of the draft to get a 2nd or 3rd round pick
- Fill some more holes in the draft

Not a bad plan, IMHO.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

If he was signed to compete with Grossman I would not have a problem with that.
I would not give anything up for him though.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

I'm surprised that silly bastard.....Bud made the right decision!

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

I wouldnt mind giving him a chance.... but he needs a Tony Dungy in his life or some type of mentor/life coach/psychologist

Anyone know how bad his ligament issue is supposed to be?

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

As a bargain basement FA we should absolutely give him a shot. Biggest issue though is like someone said, he needs a down-to-earth mentor and we don't have one here.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

Shanahan must be entertaining the possibility. Outside of maybe Brian Griese, all the QBs who ever played for him had mobility as their strong suit.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

no way!,no how!.we don't need another "bad egg" at redskins park.I do agree we now have a problem with the titans ahead of us looking to draft a QB.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

Vince Young needs mental health treatment before he can be fair to himself and the NFL. This is not a joke. Vince Young is not a mentally well person. He has had tons of red flags over the years, the biggest one being suicide watch in 2008, but nobody i dont think has really reached out to him to try and help.

He needs to at least take a serious look at some kind of outpatient thing before trying the rigors of the NFL again. No team is going to want to shell out very much for him for this very reason. Untreated, Vince Young is a ticking time bomb who could be only moments away from going off on the team, fans, and head coach, like he did Jeff Fisher.

He is exactly the kind of troubled player we would shell out big bucks for in the past, and he is now exactly the kind of player that Shanahan and Co. need to steer clear from.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

There is no way we are signing vince young, he is not the answer for our team. Please stay away.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

time to break out the vince young overrated thread again? i think the argument was officially laid to rest.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

Since it would be a trade to get him I think it would be a bad idea. Would we have to give up picks if he is released and we pick him up?

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

I'm not sure there's room here for both Young...and Alex Smith...

Seriously though, there are already rumors of Oakland being interested

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

^ SS stop ****ing with me!! With this smith shit

Anyways so much for JC and his stability in Oakland lol

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

Maybe we can trade mcnabb and Fat Al in a package deal to the titans for a pair of back to back 3rd rounders?

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

[quote=sdskinsfan2001;775549]There is no way we are signing vince young, he is not the answer for our team. Please stay away.[/quote]


Many said that about McNabb.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

Good move by the Titans. They weren't going anywhere with VY.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

Holy Crap!!! CHeck out the poll on ESPN.com on Vince Young, even Texans dont want any part of the guy!!!!!!!! I wouldnt want him either but i expected dumbass texans to want him!!

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

[quote=Bucket;775564]Maybe we can trade mcnabb and Fat Al in a package deal to the titans for a pair of back to back 3rd rounders?[/quote]

I've been thinking of a trade like this for the past couple weeks w/a couple of teams. In the past such deals were near impossible for us to gain anything in, but w/Allen running the biz I have confidence that McNabb & AH wil bring something in return, albeit probably less than we expect.

I could see Tenn. interested in McNabb if Collins isn't there. Is he under contract next year? I think Minnesota is still a possibility too.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

[quote=SmootSmack;775556]I'm not sure there's room here for both Young...and Alex Smith...

Seriously though, there are already rumors of Oakland being interested[/quote]

Why? They have JC?

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

[quote=Chico23231;775583]Why? They have JC?[/quote]

I think its because JC is just JC, meaning that he is very inconsistent. Some days he is horrible, some days he plays great. They most likely want stability at QB, especially now that they will be having a new coach.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

So I guess this means Fisher is coming back.

VY could be scary good if he ever gets his head on straight. I'm not counting on that happening though.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

[quote=Alvin Walton;775576]Many said that about McNabb.[/quote]

And they were probably right.

Re: Titans to either trade or release Vince Young
 

No no no no no no no!