I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

Ok. So on this other board we play this mock draft GM game. Basically you get a team and all of its players and picks and you contact the other teams GMs and try to make deals and trades to improve your roster. I got the Redskins and would like you guys to tell me how i did.

Washington Redskins
Quarterback
[COLOR="DarkOrange"]Ryan Tannehill[/COLOR] | Rex Grossman | John Beck | Jonathon Crompton

Wide Receiver 1
Santana Moss | Leonard Hankerson | Brandon Banks | Anthony Armstrong | Niles Paul
Wide Receiver 2
[COLOR="blue"]Lance Moore[/COLOR] | Jabar Gaffney | Donte' Stallworth | Terrence Austin | David Anderson | Aldrick Robinson

Running Back
Clinton Portis | Roy Helu | Evan Royster
Fullback
Darrel Young | Mike Sellers

Tight End
Fred Davis | Logan Paulsen | Richard Quinn | Rob Myers

Left Offensive Tackle
Trent Williams | Willie Smith | Sean Locklear
Left Offensive Guard
[COLOR="Blue"]Anthony Herrera[/COLOR] | Kory Lichtensteiger | Maurice Hurt |
Center
Will Montgomery | Erik Cook
Right Offensive Guard
Chris Chester | Nevin McCaskill
Right Offensive Tackle
Riley Reiff | Tyler Polumbus

Left Defensive End
Adam Carriker | Kedric Golston | Kentwan Balmer
Nose Tackle
Barry Cofield | Chris Neild | Chris Baker
Right Defensive End
Stephen Bowen | Jarvis Jenkins | Darrion Scott | Doug Worthington

Left Outside Linebacker
Ryan Kerrigan | Lorenzo Alexander | Markus White
Left Inside Linebacker
London Fletcher | [COLOR="DarkOrange"]James Michael Johnson[/COLOR] | Keyaron Fox
Right Inside Linebacker
Perry Riley | Rocky McIntosh
Right Outside Linebacker
Brian Orakpo | Rob Jackson

Left Cornerback
DeAngelo Hall | [COLOR="DarkOrange"]Stephon Gilmore[/COLOR] | Phillip Buchanon | Kevin Barnes
Right Cornerback
Josh Wilson | [COLOR="DarkOrange"]Coryell Judie[/COLOR] Byron Westbrook | Brandyn Thompson
Strong Safety
DeJon Gomes | Travon Bellamy
Free Safety
Oshiomogho Atogwe | Reed Doughty

Kicker (FG)
Graham Gano
Punter
Sav Rocca
Long Snapper
Nick Sundberg

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

Clinton Portis. LOL

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

Is this serious.

Honestly, I don't think you did that well.

The fact that you brought back Clinton Portis and let Tim Hightower go, is enough to tell me you weren't that serious about it.

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

Terrible close thread

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

[quote=artmonkforhallofamein07;889081]Is this serious.

Honestly, I don't think you did that well.

The fact that you brought back Clinton Portis and let Tim Hightower go, is enough to tell me you weren't that serious about it.[/quote]

actually i never traded hightower i forgot to add him when i was adding the IR players.........Thank you for reminding me about him lol

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

You kept Banks, that's an automatic fail.

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

Riley Rieff is terribly overrated.

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

I would be furious if any of this happened. You basically have Grossman as the opening day starter...

Sorry but wtf

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

Keep your day job

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

After reviewing your post, here is what I think:

I think the mods should raise the minimum required posts to allow members to start new threads from 10 to 100.

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

[quote=BigHairedAristocrat;889112]After reviewing your post, here is what I think:

I think the mods should raise the minimum required posts to allow members to start new threads from 10 to 100.[/quote]

:lol: :laughing2

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

I stopped reading at Portis.

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

[IMG]http://i54.tinypic.com/2r43d7c.png[/IMG]


Even Rex Grossman thinks this is bad.

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

[quote=Mattyk;889115]I stopped reading at Portis.[/quote]

Thats right where I stopped too.

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

Could u put a link to how it all went down? This looks odd as shit.

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

c- grade

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

[quote=Ninjafitz;889078]~(your valiant effort as GM)[/quote]

I don't know who a lot of your picks are but judging based on the ones I know:

o i like Tannehill but very dissappointed that you have cart blanche yet still chose to carry Grossman, Beck and Crompton

o i'll be nice an assume the Portis was a joke, right?

o i would draft another TE or keep Cooley

o not sure if Herrera is an upgrade from Lichtensteiger

o Sean Locklear? Locklear better hope Mike Shanahan doesn't catch him alone on the street

o i like having a long term upgrade and solution at RT its probably one of the better moves you made and ironically you forgot to highlight it

o no upgrade at Safety? tisk, tisk

o no major upgrade at WR, sure Lance Moore is a nice WR but he's the type of receiver we already have

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

Ninjas aren't as cool as they once were it seems

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

[quote=30gut;889179]I don't know who a lot of your picks are but judging based on the ones I know:

o i like Tannehill but very dissappointed that you have cart blanche yet still chose to carry Grossman, Beck and Crompton

o i'll be nice an assume the Portis was a joke, right?

o i would draft another TE or keep Cooley

o not sure if Herrera is an upgrade from Lichtensteiger

o Sean Locklear? Locklear better hope Mike Shanahan doesn't catch him alone on the street

o i like having a long term upgrade and solution at RT its probably one of the better moves you made and ironically you forgot to highlight it

o no upgrade at Safety? tisk, tisk

o no major upgrade at WR, sure Lance Moore is a nice WR but he's the type of receiver we already have[/quote]

All of this

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

so, you raised zombie threads to pump your post count for this? as a 49ers fan playing redskins gm?

just, well, it looks like you don't even know who's on the team now and haven't been following them at all. 4 tes? rob myers? 8 corners? 11 wrs? you know we already had a thread for this and it's about 2 months old... you probably should have at least looked at it for "research."

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

Redskins Nation would be banging down your door! CP26 can't even play flag football Donte' Stallworth will not be back and the fact that we keep our picks and make these picks!?!?! I did enjoy reading it thou.

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

What is your obsession with Tannehill?

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

[quote=SmootSmack;889181]Ninjas aren't as cool as they once were it seems[/quote]

[IMG]http://myspace.roflposters.com/images/rofl/myspace/1242938016930.jpg.%5Broflposters.com%5D.myspace.jpg[/IMG]

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

ok to address everyone in order for me to improve the team I had to get other players that would make deals with me the roster is huge and obviously would be skimmed down. Basically I ended up with 3 players with a first round grade all at positions of need for the redskins.

We are starting a new game soon maybe if you told me what you guys thought were your biggest needs i could address it better.........

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

This thread is dumb.

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

[quote=redskins5044;889200]this thread is dumb.[/quote]

.. .---..-...

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

[quote=redskins5044;889200]This thread is dumb.[/quote]

offseason

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

[quote=Chico23231;889206]offseason[/quote]

Yep. :doh:

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

[quote=los panda;889177]c- grade[/quote]

In the Locker Room this thread gets a capital F.

In the Fantasy Football forums (where it is now) it gets a generous B.

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

Is there such a thing as a "Mercy" Lock..........

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

[quote=Ninjafitz;889198]ok to address everyone in order for me to improve the team I had to get other players that would make deals with me the roster is huge and obviously would be skimmed down. Basically I ended up with 3 players with a first round grade all at positions of need for the redskins.

We are starting a new game soon maybe if you told me what you guys thought were your biggest needs i could address it better.........[/quote]

1. Franchise QB
2. #1 CB / #1 WR
3. #1 WR / #1 CB
4. OL (RT or g/c) and safety

if we get a #1 cb (like claiborne or grimes) hall is probably gone.
cooley stays most likely unless his health is just awful, he's cheap, we have lots of cash.

WR will be a FA signing, franchise QB will be our #1 draft pick, OL will probably be a FA deal (like grubbs). we have some decent OL guys, but the starters are weak, so bumping 1 or 2 to backups would be great.

we'd love another DE too, but i don't think it's a huge need and I don't see a guy to fall over ourselves to get (unless rak leaves in trade).

this has all been covered in the 2012 redskins thread, so i don't know why you haven't looked at that or posted this there, since that's where it belongs.

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

Everyone is bashing this thread, but I think it is amazing. Granted his team sucks, but think of the general concept. 32 people pretending to be gms, and going through an offseason. Mods, we should organize something like this. Make some rules for free agency and trades (maybe have probability (like a random number generator) play into it or have a judge rule what would happen or what is fair ). Make sure everyone knows their cap situation. It would be hella intense but I would love it. Get 32 dedicated people, and randomly assign them to 32 teams and have a free agency day, then have a draft day. Super nerds like myself would love that. If you guys are on board....I'm in the 32 for sure.

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

[quote=skinster;889385]Everyone is bashing this thread, but I think it is amazing. Granted his team sucks, but think of the general concept. 32 people pretending to be gms, and going through an offseason. Mods, we should organize something like this. Make some rules for free agency and trades (maybe have probability (like a random number generator) play into it or have a judge rule what would happen or what is fair ). Make sure everyone knows their cap situation. It would be hella intense but I would love it. Get 32 dedicated people, and randomly assign them to 32 teams and have a free agency day, then have a draft day. Super nerds like myself would love that. If you guys are on board....I'm in the 32 for sure.[/quote]


we did that once with a full 7 round mock draft... we had 32 people sign up, yet i ended up gm'ing like 10 teams due to drop outs. It was cool, but too much work.

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

[quote=skinster;889385]Everyone is bashing this thread, but I think it is amazing. Granted his team sucks, but think of the general concept. 32 people pretending to be gms, and going through an offseason. Mods, we should organize something like this. Make some rules for free agency and trades (maybe have probability (like a random number generator) play into it or have a judge rule what would happen or what is fair ). Make sure everyone knows their cap situation. It would be hella intense but I would love it. Get 32 dedicated people, and randomly assign them to 32 teams and have a free agency day, then have a draft day. Super nerds like myself would love that. If you guys are on board....I'm in the 32 for sure.[/quote]

I nominate you to organize it.

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

[quote=That Guy;889389]we did that once with a full 7 round mock draft... we had 32 people sign up, yet i ended up gm'ing like 10 teams due to drop outs. It was cool, but too much work.[/quote]

I'd be in for 3 rounds max, 2 rounds ideally. 7 is just too much. I'd just be picking random people at positions of need after 2 rounds. But we def need 32 people for this game to work. Nobody should gm more than 1 team.

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

[quote=skinster;889399]I'd be in for 3 rounds max, 2 rounds ideally. 7 is just too much. I'd just be picking random people at positions of need after 2 rounds. But we def need 32 people for this game to work. Nobody should gm more than 1 team.[/quote]

until they go mia when they should be picking etc. NCAA has great stat pages and all that, and you can kinda see late round gems there, like cooley, who had 102 catches as a fullback (b back, in his system the b back was really only there to catch passes)... and the lb's / safeties with 120 tackles a year normally are the ones that end up as productive late rounders.

you can look up the old threads, but it took a lot of work to organize, only to have some people ignore all the research and just pick a name from a hat or choose a non-need position 3 rounds too early or whatnot.

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

Are you a Dallas/Philly/New Jersey fan?

Why would you do this to our team?

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

And I thought MY threads were useless......

Re: I was GM for the Redskins for this game. Tell me how I did.
 

[quote=JGisLordOfTheRings;923750]And I thought MY threads were useless......[/quote]

lol just read this thread and got a kick out of it