Hall of Fame 2009 Nominee List
 

[url=http://www.nfl.com/halloffame/story?id=09000d5d80c082e3&template=with-video-with-comments&confirm=true]Hall of Fame announces 2009 nominee list[/url]

Re: Hall of Fame 2009 Nominee List
 

i'd say bm has no real shot. i mean 23k special teams yards is nice and all, but if he were a better player, he wouldn't have been relegated like that... AND comparing his TD production to devin hester's isn't very impressive either.

Re: Hall of Fame 2009 Nominee List
 

Jessie Armstead? Hmmm...

Re: Hall of Fame 2009 Nominee List
 

John Randle and Bruce Smith are a lock.

Re: Hall of Fame 2009 Nominee List
 

amounth of redskins eligible is sweet.

Re: Hall of Fame 2009 Nominee List
 

My picks for getting in:

Russ Grimm
Bruce Smith
Shannon Sharpe
Clay Matthews
Darren Woodson
Ray Guy



Of course, we know the voters are on crack sometimes (Mike Irvin reference for getting in before Monk).

Re: Hall of Fame 2009 Nominee List
 

[quote=Buster;495214]My picks for getting in:

Russ Grimm
Bruce Smith
Shannon Sharpe
Clay Matthews
Darren Woodson
Ray Guy



Of course, we know the voters are on crack sometimes (Mike Irvin reference for getting in before Monk).[/quote]

I thought only five get in each year.

Re: Hall of Fame 2009 Nominee List
 

[quote=the article linked in Post 1, to answer firstdown's question]While there is no set number for any class of enshrinees, the ground rules provide that between four and seven new members will be selected.[/quote]

My choices for this year:
Bruce Smith
Rod Woodson
Russ Grimm
Richard Dent
Ray Guy

Re: Hall of Fame 2009 Nominee List
 

I think Hall voters need to stop ignoring the contributions of special teams players. It's just ridiculous that someone like Ray Guy can't get a sniff of the Hall. B-Mitch is definitely deserving based on his overall play. The guy could do it all.

Re: Hall of Fame 2009 Nominee List
 

By Peter King's logic, Shannon Sharpe doesn't deserve it because he was surpassed by Tony Gonzalez as the all-time yardage, receptions, and TD leader.

Re: Hall of Fame 2009 Nominee List
 

Without doing the research I'm just not sure about Jesse Armstead. Sure, a solid player, but HOF worthy?

Re: Hall of Fame 2009 Nominee List
 

[quote=redsk1;495258]Without doing the research I'm just not sure about Jesse Armstead. Sure, a solid player, but HOF worthy?[/quote]

A case could be made for him. He's a 5 time Pro Bowl player and his [URL="http://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/A/ArmsJe00.htm"]stats[/URL] are pretty solid. In his prime he was one of the better players at his position. I doubt he would get in but his resume is quietly better than some might realize.

Re: Hall of Fame 2009 Nominee List
 

[quote=firstdown;495232]I thought only five get in each year.[/quote]

[quote]There is no set number of new enshrinees, but the Committee’s current ground rules do stipulate that between four and seven new members will be selected each year. [/quote]

source: [url=http://www.profootballhof.com/hof/SelectionProcessFAQ.jsp]Hall of Famers: Selection Process FAQ - Pro Football Hall of Fame[/url]