Madden 11 player ratings: Redskins
 

[url=http://espn.go.com/videogames/madden11?teamId=26]Video Games - Madden 11 Ratings - ESPN[/url]

Overall not bad. A few of my minor gripes:

Cooley an 89? He should be above 90.

Fred Davis is too low at 76, I would put him at an 80 at least.

Where's Jammal Brown? Not a huge deal as I'm sure he'll be on the roster when the game comes out, or with the first update at the worst. He'll make a big difference on the OL.

Big Mike Williams is really overrated with an 80. I would put him closer to 70.

I would switch ratings with Doughty and Horton. Horton seems to still be living off his reputation from his rookie year.

Re: Madden 11 player ratings: Redskins
 

For what Haynesworth is being paid, shouldn't we at least get a stud Madden player? An 86? Seriously?

Re: Madden 11 player ratings: Redskins
 

[quote=Skinsfanatic;712068]For what Haynesworth is being paid, shouldn't we at least get a stud Madden player? An 86? Seriously?[/quote]

I would bet that's because he's listed as a DE. If you move him to DT his rating would probably go up. Same if you move Orakpo to DE.

I don't care what he wants AH is playing the nose in my D. :)

Re: Madden 11 player ratings: Redskins
 

lol @ having to enter a 12 button combo just to get haynesworth out the tunnel.

Re: Madden 11 player ratings: Redskins
 

Who is C. Oldenburg on the OL?

Where is Capers and Cook? Madden never quite gets the rookies right.

Also is Landry really an 89 after last years performances. He got burnt like toast!

Re: Madden 11 player ratings: Redskins
 

[quote=artmonkforhallofamein07;712077]Who is C. Oldenburg on the OL?

Where is Capers and Cook? Madden never quite gets the rookies right.

Also is Landry really an 89 after last years performances. He got burnt like toast![/quote]

Says he's an 87. I would probably put him around 85

Re: Madden 11 player ratings: Redskins
 

[quote=Mattyk;712070]I would bet that's because he's listed as a DE. If you move him to DT his rating would probably go up. Same if you move Orakpo to DE.

[B]I don't care what he wants AH is playing the nose in my D. :)[/quote][/B]

Didn't you promise him he would be able to play his game and attack the QB?

Re: Madden 11 player ratings: Redskins
 

[quote=Mattyk;712058][url=http://espn.go.com/videogames/madden11?teamId=26]Video Games - Madden 11 Ratings - ESPN[/url]

Overall not bad. A few of my minor gripes:

Cooley an 89? He should be above 90.

Fred Davis is too low at 76, I would put him at an 80 at least.

Where's Jammal Brown? Not a huge deal as I'm sure he'll be on the roster when the game comes out, or with the first update at the worst. He'll make a big difference on the OL.

Big Mike Williams is really overrated with an 80. I would put him closer to 70.

I would switch ratings with Doughty and Horton. Horton seems to still be living off his reputation from his rookie year.[/quote]

Horton's persence and awareness is far above and beyond Doughty. An interception can hit him in the helmet, and he will be looking a the receivers feet.

Re: Madden 11 player ratings: Redskins
 

Landry - Tackling an 80??? His Play Rec is right at a 61

Brennan - Accuracy and 84??? Higher than McNabb????

Just a couple of minor gripes. Overall I like the new rating system unveiled last year.

Re: Madden 11 player ratings: Redskins
 

[quote=artmonkforhallofamein07;712077]Who is C. Oldenburg on the OL?

Where is Capers and Cook? Madden never quite gets the rookies right.

[B]Also is Landry really an 89 after last years performances. He got burnt like toast[/B]![/quote]

yeah high 80s as a FS is a stretch. maybe mid 80s as SS though.

Re: Madden 11 player ratings: Redskins
 

[quote=artmonkforhallofamein07;712077]Who is C. Oldenburg on the OL?

Where is Capers and Cook? Madden never quite gets the rookies right.

Also is Landry really an 89 after last years performances. He got burnt like toast![/quote]

Clint Oldenburg. Signed him to the practice squad toward the end of last season I believe

Re: Madden 11 player ratings: Redskins
 

This is pretty depressing to look at. We suck.

Re: Madden 11 player ratings: Redskins
 

I don't think the roster looks that bad at all, middle of the road kind of team

Re: Madden 11 player ratings: Redskins
 

Well I don't like to look at the Madden roster as the final 53 of the Real Redskins, and it never takes in account the break out players for which none of us know. Also with out Jamaal Brown and without knowing what we have in TW yet this isw more of a fantasy deal then anything of actual fact.

Madden is cool and fun, but is not a very good indication of how teams may fare year in and year out.

Re: Madden 11 player ratings: Redskins
 

[quote=artmonkforhallofamein07;712111]Well I don't like to look at the Madden roster as the final 53 of the Real Redskins, and it never takes in account the break out players for which none of us know. Also with out Jamaal Brown and without knowing what we have in TW yet this isw more of a fantasy deal then anything of actual fact.

[B]Madden is cool and fun, but is not a very good indication of how teams may fare year in and year out.[/B][/quote]

Bingo. Digital 1's and 0's don't suit up on Sundays.