Ravens v. Niners Super Bowl Thread

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

On the other hand look at this view, and tell me why the Ref didn't call a personal foul. Its clear Reed puts his helmet right on Crabtree's before he is a runner.

I think thats a great play to jar the ball lose. I dont see anything wrong with that play.

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

It's kinda a shame that we started the season talking about the refs and the lockout, now the last game has some questionable calls to (both ways for sure, but that doesn't make it right).

I hope that whatever system they have put in place for grading and evaluation, next season sees better quality ref'ing all the way around.

I thought the refs last night did a nice job. They let em play and that's how it should be. I didn't see any ticky tack BS that you normally see. Well called game.

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by Lotus

I thought that the last no-call was a good one. Both players were guilty and either could have been flagged. It would have sucked if the Super Bowl had been decided by arbitrarily pointing the finger at one of those guys. It was a good time to let 'em play.

agree agree agree


Look, criticize the play call. A fade route to Crabtree on 4th down? Horrible and pathetic. Thats a first down playcall and you need to throw that to a physical reciever who knows create space. Crabtree is not close to that type of guy. Horrible playcall.

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

I think thats a great play to jar the ball lose. I dont see anything wrong with that play.

Nothing wrong w/ this play at all. Great play by Reed. Reed was all over the place last night. Good to see him get a ring.

[Evilgrin]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

Nothing wrong w/ this play at all. Great play by Reed. Reed was all over the place last night. Good to see him get a ring.

Ed Reed is number 20, that isn't Ed Reed?

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

Nothing wrong w/ this play at all. Great play by Reed. Reed was all over the place last night. Good to see him get a ring.

Sorry, I said Reed, it wasn't. As for a great play, I dunno, I thought you can't lead to the helmet of a defenseless receiver which is what I believe Crabtree was, otherwise it should have been a fumble out of bounds, not incomplete.

I am willing to bet that 22 sees a fine come his way for that one.

[Mattyk]

I really didn't have a big problem with the refs, I thought they let a little too much go but at the same time they called it fairly evenly for both sides. They let them play for the most part.

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

Sorry, I said Reed, it wasn't. As for a great play, I dunno, I thought you can't lead to the helmet of a defenseless receiver which is what I believe Crabtree was, otherwise it should have been a fumble out of bounds, not incomplete.

I am willing to bet that 22 sees a fine come his way for that one.

22 is jimmy Smith

[donofriose]

The refs did a great job. They did not call anything unless it was obvious. Which is how it should be. I hate when refs aren't sure but they throw the flag anyway. You see the ref look right at crabtree and Smith battling, Crabtree was engaging with Smith just as much as Crabtree was. I would have hated to see the same result of the Miami OSU national Championship game. SF played dirty and so did Baltimore. Refs let it go and let the players play. The best official is the quiet one. Going down 28-6 is what lost the game.

[skinsfaninok]

Lmao Skip bayless is a bum.. whenever he picks a game and he losses he always says he got robbed lol

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by donofriose

The refs did a great job. They did not call anything unless it was obvious. Which is how it should be. I hate when refs aren't sure but they throw the flag anyway. You see the ref look right at crabtree and Smith battling, Crabtree was engaging with Smith just as much as Crabtree was. I would have hated to see the same result of the Miami OSU national Championship game. SF played dirty and so did Baltimore. Refs let it go and let the players play. The best official is the quiet one. Going down 28-6 is what lost the game.

I agree about that, and honestly, no power outage, and I think that game remains a blowout. Imagine the crying that Bmore fans would be doing if they lost after the power outage. Might even be worse then them winning it.

[donofriose]

Originally Posted by Mattyk

I really didn't have a big problem with the refs, I thought they let a little too much go but at the same time they called it fairly evenly for both sides. They let them play for the most part.

I agree. Let them play. As long as they are calling the same game both ways. Which they were. Like the Seattle Redskins game. Physical play in the secondary. Let them play.

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by donofriose

The refs did a great job. They did not call anything unless it was obvious. Which is how it should be. I hate when refs aren't sure but they throw the flag anyway. You see the ref look right at crabtree and Smith battling, Crabtree was engaging with Smith just as much as Crabtree was. I would have hated to see the same result of the Miami OSU national Championship game. SF played dirty and so did Baltimore. Refs let it go and let the players play. The best official is the quiet one. Going down 28-6 is what lost the game.

Exactly. However I did think the call on Akers was a flat out joke. The refs have to be able to see that the kicker is over acting there. That gave SF 3 points.

[NC_Skins]

Super Bowl 47: 49ers coach Jim Harbaugh goes down complaining | NJ.com

[firstdown]

I to thought the refs called one of the better game i have seen them call in some time. They even let a few punches fly without throwing a flag. I know I saw 4 or 5 times where they could have thrown a flag but they let the players play. Great game all around and my dad wo $1000 in his pool when the score went to 31/29. If the game would have ended at that score he would have won another 15 grand.