[CultBrennan59]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

How is Heath Shuler overrated?

Current Overrated/Underrated: Pierre Garcon/London Fletcher
All-Time Underrated: James Thrash



Seriously though

All-time Overrated: probably Chip Lohmiller or Doug Williams. Chip wasn't quite as good as history remembers him. And Williams had great (undeniably great) moments for the Redskins but in all he only played 16 games for us and most of it was a rather average career here. I think some think he was a stud for years on end here

All-time Underrated: Mark Rypien. He was a pretty solid QB for more than just that 1991 season.

Current overrated: Really tempted to say Roy Helu. He's one of my favorite players on the team, but overall he's not as awesome/the game changer that we'd like to believe.

Current Underrated: Not sure Josh Morgan gets enough love for all the little things he does. Also think Chris Chester is a bit underrated

Coming out of college and what skins fans thought he was going to be. I really couldn't think of anyone other than..Clinton Portis.