Commanders Post at The Warpath - View Single Post

12thMan · 09-18-2005, 05:22 PM

I was recently looking at the draft class of '04, now that they all have a year under their belts, and was thinking if I were the Redskins GM/VP/Snyder/Gibbs/Cerrato would I have made the same choice in picking Sean Taylor with the fifth overall pick or someone else?

I must admit, I still would have selected ST with that pick. Considering all the other available choices and the positions they play, I think Taylor would have and has added more impact to our team. Even considering Big Ben was available, I still would have gone with Taylor.

"Homerism" aside, would any of you have made a different choice....even as much as we love ST?

I separated the first 10 picks from the top fifteen. Just to make it a little more interesting.

1. Eli Manning QB - Chargers
2. Robert Gallery T- Raiders
3. Larry Fitzgerald WR - Cardinals
4. Philip Rivers QB - Giants
5. Sean Taylor FS - Redskins
6. Kellen Winslow TE -Browns
7. Roy Williams WR - Lions
8. DeAngelo Hall CB - Falcons
9. Reggie Williams WR -Jaguars
10. Dunta Robinson CB-Texans

***********************************
picks 11-15

11. Ben Roethlisberger QB Steelers
12. Johnathan Vilma ILB Jets
13. Lee Evans WR Bills
14. Tommie Harris DT Bears Chicago
15. Michael Clayton WR Bucs

09-18-2005, 05:22 PM	#1
12thMan MVP Join Date: May 2005 Location: washington, D.C. Posts: 11,460	Would you have still picked Sean Taylor? I was recently looking at the draft class of '04, now that they all have a year under their belts, and was thinking if I were the Redskins GM/VP/Snyder/Gibbs/Cerrato would I have made the same choice in picking Sean Taylor with the fifth overall pick or someone else? I must admit, I still would have selected ST with that pick. Considering all the other available choices and the positions they play, I think Taylor would have and has added more impact to our team. Even considering Big Ben was available, I still would have gone with Taylor. "Homerism" aside, would any of you have made a different choice....even as much as we love ST? I separated the first 10 picks from the top fifteen. Just to make it a little more interesting. 1. Eli Manning QB - Chargers 2. Robert Gallery T- Raiders 3. Larry Fitzgerald WR - Cardinals 4. Philip Rivers QB - Giants 5. Sean Taylor FS - Redskins 6. Kellen Winslow TE -Browns 7. Roy Williams WR - Lions 8. DeAngelo Hall CB - Falcons 9. Reggie Williams WR -Jaguars 10. Dunta Robinson CB-Texans *********************************** picks 11-15 11. Ben Roethlisberger QB Steelers 12. Johnathan Vilma ILB Jets 13. Lee Evans WR Bills 14. Tommie Harris DT Bears Chicago 15. Michael Clayton WR Bucs