Quote:
Originally Posted by KI Skins Fan
I asked you about that and you said that a 2:1 good to bad games ratio wasn't good enough. In your latest post you say that he shouldn't be signed unless he plays "great" the rest of this season. Great? Is that all you want? Just for him to become great right away? You are more inconsistent than Kirk.
Well, you are consistent in that Kirk can't play well enough to suit you even if he wins Offensive Player of the Week.
|
I would suggest I have been entirely consistent in my position. Here is the prior conversation:
Quote:
Originally Posted by JoeRedskin
I want at least two or three games of consistent good play - meaning: 1) No bonehead INT's; and 2) consistent accuracy with his passes.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by KI Skins Fan
... Would you say he's getting there if he can produce two or three good games in a row with one or two poor games in between the good ones? (my emphasis)
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by JoeRedskin
Not really. To me, that's his current MO.
|
Here is the quote to which my 2:1 comment was responsive:
Quote:
Originally Posted by artmonkforhallofamein07
... My eyes tell me he has made some strides this year in the mental aspect of his game after he makes mistakes. But what they also tell me is that he has yet to put together back to back good games, he has yet to play a good game on the road and he his good games are in the middle of multiple bad games. BOTTTOM LINE the jury is still well out on him and until consistent play is accomplished I don't feel he is the future.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by JoeRedskin
My eyes are seeing the exact same thing.
Not looking for him to be flawless, just looking for the good games to be about a 2:1 ratio of good games to the bad ones. Consistently.
|
If KC has one or two good games for every one or two bad games he is just the same old KC. If he strings two or three good games on either side of a SINGLE bad game, then I think he has shown significant improvement. With nine games to go, if he has only two "bad" games, that's improvement. He doesn't have to be great or even good in the rest, just no bonehead interceptions and decent accuracy.
Quote:
Originally Posted by KI Skins Fan
BTW, what have you got in mind for Plan B if Kirk isn't re-signed?
|
Honestly, don't know. Don't know who is likely to be available. My responses have been to the question "Who is KC" not "If you don't think KC is next year's QB, what's the plan?"
KC
may be the best option for next year, but to me that's a entirely different question from who he is NOW. To me, he is the same guy he has been for the last THREE AND A HALF YEARS. Decent game, good game, dear-god-how-he-still-be-in-the-league game, less than good game, really good game. All mixed in together.
You see something that makes you think he can change that. Okay, fair enough. I don't. At the same time, he may end up be being the best option for next year.