Quote:
|
Originally Posted by BrudLee
I believe Aikman is a Hall of Fame player, but a QB who holds no records, never dominated statistically, and was surrounded by as much talent as he was isn't a "lead pipe lock" for the Hall on his first ballot.
This isn't a "Slam Aikman" feeling - he plays an overvalued position, and while he was very good at it, I don't know that he was dominant in his era at the position. He should and will be inducted, but he's no slam dunk.
|
I agree, if any QB deserves to make it this year it should be Moon. Look at his stats, he was a great QB on shity teams.
Passing Attempts: 6823
Passing Comp: 3988
Comp %: 58.4%
Passing Yards: 49325
Passing TD: 291
For each catagory this is where he is ranked among the others.
Passing Attempts: 4th, only Favre, Elway, Marino ahead of him
Passing Comp: 4th, with the same 3 ahead of him
Passing Yards: 4th, with the same 3 ahead of him
Passing TD: 5th, with the same 3 ahead of him plus Tarkenton
So if you look at the company he is with, he is more than deserving of a 1st time ballot to make the HOF.
All of my information was taken from this web site:
http://www.pro-football-reference.co...s/MoonWa00.htm
http://www.pro-football-reference.com/misc/ptd.htm