Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Riggo44
You guy's must be nuts! Mcnabb is one of the top 5 QB's in the NFL. I would take him in a heart beat over any QB on our roster! |
so u want our team to lose even more than they have the past 8-9 years? almost a 5th of his total tds r on the ground and his career qb rating is only 79.3 while ramsey's coming into his 3rd year is already at 74.2 and brunnels career passer rating is 85.2.
I like redskins8588's list except brooks isn't in the top 8 and you forgot Pettington.
in my opinion the 10 best qbs at this time and their career ratings
1.) Manning=88.1
2.)Brady=85.9
3.)Pettington=95.1
4.)Culpepper=88.0
5.)Mcnair=84.1
6.)Favre=86.9
7.)Garcia=88.3
8.)Green=86.1
9.)Brunnel=85.2
10.)B.Johnson=84.1
those r all qbs I'd take over mcnabb if I needed to win one game or even the entire playoffs.
and if vick adapts to the west coast offense he'll be in this list as well and hasselback(matt) is a qb on the rise.
the thing people seem to do with mcnabb is confuse atheliticism for talent and one of these days his errent passes are going to get one of his teammates severely hurt and if he ever sustains a torn ligament, tendon, or muscle he will never be the same cuz he's shown he doesn't have the skills to be a pocket passer.