Quote:
|
Originally Posted by JWsleep
I agree, Memphis. Winning talks, the rest is just numbers. Mcnabb completed a crazy 4th and 26 to beat the pack, and Favre threw a crazy INT.
|
anyone watching that game saw that mcnabbs pass was almost as bad as favre's except green bay's defense flubbed up the coverage and played 2 soft. I don't doubt the importance of his leadership to their team, but lets face it, a majority of the eagles victories have been from the play of their defense or special teams.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by memphisskin
Manning, McNair, Favre, Brady and maybe Culpepper. Pennington and Green have yet to even reach the conference championship game, and I'm going to assume that throwing Jeff Garcia in this conversation is some kind of joke.
|
just cuz u might not respect garcia, doesn't dispute his productivity with practically just owens, hearst, and barlow to throw too the past few years.
Is mcnabb good? yeah, but is he one of the top ten qbs in the league just cuz his team wins a lot whether its with his help or not? no, cuz if u make that argument then how come jay fiedler isn't considered an elite qb since he has one of, if not the highest, winning percentages of any active qbs?