[wolfeskins]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Manning may never win a championship, but if there is really something special to Brady, he can win 3 more easy, right?

The pro Brady arguement is based on two things

1) Tossing out any and all of Manning regular season accomplishments-basically assuming either regular season equality, or insignificance.
2) Proof that Manning's cognitive clarity is affected by playoff style pressure.

It's difficult, for any QB, to win on the road in inclimate weather in the playoffs, against the leagues best D's. Manning has yet to be successful (in 3 tries since 2002), Brady failed in Denver anyway. I'm not sure I'd attribute this phenomenon to playoff pressure as much as it just seems like a situation that the QB is going to struggle in. Manning has, Brady has.

just because a person is pro-brady does not mean that they are anti-manning. i'm a huge fan of both of them but when push comes to shove i'd take brady over manning in the big game.