Quote:
Originally Posted by wilsowilso
not top five no way. Brady is better and that lame excuse that it's all Belichik is such a cop out.
|
No, the "excuse" is he's only played 6 seasons. The "prediction" is that he will falter once Belichik is gone.
Quote:
|
So if Young is the greatest all time how come only one Super Bowl appearance?????
|
So Marino can't be considered the greatest of all time in your mind????
Quote:
|
I mean he was on some really good teams and if he is the best ever or even top five why does he have so little to show for it? He was a great QB, but top five only in some stats which really don't mean much without the big game heroics.
|
Please see other informative posts on this thread like when I said he encountered a dynasty in Dallas etc. I've already explained this. You need to remember this is a TEAM sport. I don't discredit Marino cause he never won any super bowl.
Quote:
|
Brady dominates Young in his post season record. You can have the other stats all day.
|
Only by 3 games, but right now he does, who's to say he doesn't play in 5 more postseason games and loses them all? Like I said, too early for Brady, can't count him yet. 6 seasons is not enough. Yes, Brady has had a GREAT postseason career in his career, but that does not make him a top 5 all time QB. Is Timmy Smith a top 10 all time RB because he had an amazing game? Obviously, no. We need to see how he finishes his career.
I don't think Brady is as good as everyone thinks. Manning is, but Brady isn't. My point will be proven when Belichik retires.
Quote:
|
Oh and to remain on topic Vick sucks and dog fighting is for fools.
|
100% agree.