Quote:
Originally Posted by Schneed10
Well now hang on folks.
Vinny was director of college scouting with the 49ers when they won a SB. He was Lou Holtz's top scouting guy when ND won a national championship. And if Gibbs is saying that Vinny and his crew had a major hand in developing our roster, then he had a hand in at least some of the following:
Anthony Montgomery
Kedric Golston
Reed Doughty
Chris Cooley
Rocky McIntosh
Chris Wilson
Stephon Heyer
Jason Campbell
Carlos Rogers
Sean Taylor
Laron Landry
Then the free agents, like Griffin, Washington, Springs, etcetera.
Vinny may have had a hand in Duckett, Lloyd, and Archuleta, which were crippling moves. But if Vinny's getting credit here, then you gotta give some love.
The tough thing is, I don't think any of us really know how much of the roster-building was Gibbs, and how much was Vinny.
Either way, the coaching decision is really the critical move. Vinny as Exec VP doesn't change much in my eyes. The new coach will work with Vinny to determine personnel needs. But it's the new coach that will have to deal with the players, and all the players want GW.
|
Good post.
Just for the sake of throwing it out there, what if Vinny played a bigger role than Gibbs in the recent personnel success stories?
And I do agree with your final point. He's already been working in a similar capacity. This is mostly a change in title.