Quote:
|
Originally Posted by offiss
I was talking about contract's in a comparative fashion, because you essentially said that because Portis is our most talented player that he is our most productive player which is just not true, we all know Portis is our most talented player, but Gardner has outplayed him, if Gardner was a more talented player he would be impossible to sign because we would have to pay him like Portis, this wasen't a debate over who has more talent, it was a debate over who has been more productive, I never thought I would say it but I don't see any way we could vote for anyone on offense MVP right now other than Gardner, and I think it's hand's down.
And no I wouldn't consider Portis productive right now, if you measure production on average you will find he is below average, and if you measure production by contract then he's a bust right now, let's face it you said a lot of a WR's success is due to the QB, well so is the RB's, the sooner we get Brunell out of there the sooner player's will start filling their potential.
There are to many on this board who want to hold Ramsey to a higher accountability than Brunell, that's just not fair, Brunell was the guy brought here to step right in and be productive because of his experience, and here we are grooming a 34 year old over the hill QB with a lot of recent injury problem's, many want to bring up rookies like B. Roth and compare Ramsey to him, well how bout comparing a seasoned veteran to BR? It's obvious Brunell isn't capable of outplaying a rookie! Brunell is obviously not who Gibb's felt he would be. peace out!
|
uh, our whole offense is way below average. Portis has the majority of our offensive yards, and thats in spite of every defense stacking the line, something Gardner benefits greatly from. stop rationalizing. as bad as our offense is, the run has set up the pass by far. no one is doubling Gardner. when they stack the line, they are essentially tripling Portis. he's done the most with the least help, not even a FB to lead block for him, and his presence has done the most for this offense. he just can't do it alone. even one-dimensional teams like Denver and Minnesota, have a great oLine and passer, some other element to the mix. we have neither.