Quote:
Originally Posted by Schneed10
Actually this is a good thread IMO.
|
Whew - the Warpath collectively lets out a sigh of relief as the thread has the official Schneed10 Seal of Approval.
More threads need the "SchneedSeal"
Now on to actual discussion:
As to the punting duel - While punting may transfer easily, I am not so sure Brooks will be a lock. It seems to me that many a punter makes it with his 2nd, 3rd or 4th team out of college. If punting is so transferable, why does it take multiple teams? - Is the time to punt shorter in the NFL? Do punters take a deeper drop in the NFL? Does the ball come to the punter faster from an NFL long snapper than from a College long snapper?
I was all set to say that punters usually bounce around before they are successful. Then I did some research on punters drafted between 199-2007.
THE FOLLOWING PUNTERS STARTED THE FIRST GAME WITH THE TEAM THAT DRAFTED THEM AND ARE STILL THE STARTING PUNTER FOR THAT TEAM:
(Year/Round Drafted)
2007
4 Adam Podlesh, Jaguars
4 Daniel Sepulveda, Steelers
7 Brandon Fields, Dolphins
2006
6 Sam Koch, Ravens
7 Ryan Plackemeier, Seahawks
2005
3 Dustin Colquitt, Chiefs
2004
6 Andy Lee, 49ers
2003
5 Mike Scifres, Chargers
2000
5 Shane Lechler, Raiders
THE FOLLOWING PUNTERS ARE CURRENTLY STARTERS FOR TEAMS THAT DID NOT ORIGINALLY DRAFT THEM:
2004
7 Donnie Jones, Seahawks - Cut mid-year 2004 by Seattle, played 2005 & 2006 for Miami, in 2007 put up really good numbers as starting punter for the Rams.
2002
4 Dave Zastudil, Ravens – Started 4 years for the Ravens and then signed away by the Browns as a UFA, 2 year starter for the Browns.
2001
4 Nick Harris, Broncos – Started 2001, 2002 and 2003 with Bengals, To Detroit mid-year 2003 (not sure if it was by trade or waiver wire) and has been starter for Detroit ever since.
1999
4 Josh Bidwell, Packers - Started 4 years for Packers and then signed away by the T. Bay as a UFA, current punter for the Bucs.
THE FOLLOWING DRAFTED PUNTERS ARE OUT OF THE NFL:
2005
6 Reggie Hodges, Rams - Cut mid-year 2005.
2004
3 B.J. Sanders, Packers - Cut mid-year 2004.
2003
6 Eddie Johnson, Vikings – Cut 14th game of 2003 Season.
2002
6 Caig Jarrett, Seahawks - Cut 4th game of 2002 Season
1999
6 Brent Bartholomew, Dolphins - Played two games with the Dolphins in 1999 and seven games with the Bears in 2000.
7 Rodney Williams, Rams – Played 15 games for the Giants in 2001.
Thus, of the 19 punters drafted between 1999 and 2007, thirteen are still in the league including nine that are still starting for the team that drafted them. Four of the nineteen are still starters in the league but just for different teams. Of the four who are starting for new teams, two were signed away as UFA’s at the expiration of their rookie contracts and one has punted for only two teams. Only six are entirely out of football and, interestingly, none of these six lasted more than a year.
Thus, it seems to me, drafted punters are pretty safe bets to make it with their first team (11 of 19 is pretty good odds). Further, even if Brooks doesn’t cut it, then it will show up pretty quickly and we can probably pick Frost right back up (or just have him pull a hamstring before training camp and keep him on IR for a year as an insurance policy).
At the same time, the only punter listed as a UFA is Mitch “Boy, am I ancient” Berger.
So, in order to make the best use of the 80 man roster, and in light of the history of drafted punters, cut or stash Frost and use the roster spot on someone who can take some reps in practice. Taking this course may be dangerous if Brooks is one of the minority of drafted punters who can’t make it in the NFL as there is not a lot of veteran punters to choose from.