[rypper11]

Originally Posted by Ade Jimoh Fan Club

I voted as well; however, if I were unbiased, there's no way Horton deserves this over McFadden.

I know it'll be unpopular, but if you watch his 2 INT's and his fumble recovery, it isn't b/c he made a great play in coverage, etc... they were tipped balls and he had a horseshoe up his ass. I will definitely give him credit for catching the ball (unlike other unamed DB's on our team), but it was less amazing performance and more lucky SOB.

I'm extremely scared of Reed Doughty's coverage abilities, but he's definitely a safer play than Horton right now. I'm not ready to crown him a starter, although a few more games like this one and I will be.

By the way, the Safety I was most excited about during preseason was Kareem Moore. What's KaMo up to these days?

I agree that McFadden deserves it more but part of being a good safety is being in position and reacting correctly. No it wasn't spectacular and the fumble recovery he should have just flopped on but I'm still glad that he was in the right place.