[skinsnut]

I started him from a 2 in preseason...cause hes a rookie, the Giants game proved that.
Then after Dallas, I gave him a 3...
After Philly I gave him a 4 because it wasn't a 1 game fluke...
However,
My main perspective is this.
You give a coach a 4 if he can get you to the playoffs, You give him a 5 if you are a hall of famer or get you to the Superbowl.

Right now...If I could, I'd give him a 3.5, because the team has played down to the Rams and Lions. He has had some questionable coaching decisions, deciding to go conservative at the end of 4th quarters against weaker teams.
I think teams have figured out how to keep his offense between the 20s too.
He needs to adjust some stuff offensively to get us to score more.
That is a big step for a Rookie HC.