Commanders Post at The Warpath - View Single Post

jamf · 01-14-2009, 01:04 PM

I would not say McNabb is a HOF'er.
If you had to pick a QB to lead your team in the superbowl, Would you Pick Aikmen, Young or McNabb?
I doubt anyone here would start McNabb over those two guys.

If you looked at current NFL QBs, Which one would you want to start for your team in the Superbowl?
My top 5 is:
1: Brady
2: Peyton Manning
3: Warner
4: Brees
5: Favre

McNabb doesn't crack the top 5 list of current best QBs.

Warner: Yes. Superbowl ring, MVPs and Had another MVP type year this year.
The greatest show on turf wasn't so great without him. Leinart couldn't do anything with Fitz and Boldin last year. There's more too his game than just being the beneficiary of great WRs.

01-14-2009, 01:04 PM	#32
jamf Pro Bowl Join Date: Jul 2004 Location: San Diego Ca Posts: 5,353	Re: McNabb, Warner, and the Hall of Fame I would not say McNabb is a HOF'er. If you had to pick a QB to lead your team in the superbowl, Would you Pick Aikmen, Young or McNabb? I doubt anyone here would start McNabb over those two guys. If you looked at current NFL QBs, Which one would you want to start for your team in the Superbowl? My top 5 is: 1: Brady 2: Peyton Manning 3: Warner 4: Brees 5: Favre McNabb doesn't crack the top 5 list of current best QBs. Warner: Yes. Superbowl ring, MVPs and Had another MVP type year this year. The greatest show on turf wasn't so great without him. Leinart couldn't do anything with Fitz and Boldin last year. There's more too his game than just being the beneficiary of great WRs.