Quote:
Originally Posted by Dirtbag359
Nice list. I think if I could change it I would be tempted to drop Ben down one rung but I don't think I would go through with it. I also think that Flacco and Ryan deserve to get bumped up a level. Leinart should be a wildcard.
|
IMO, I think he solidified his status midseason in 2008. I caught some Pitt late games and the announcers kept on going on and on about how he basically stopped trying to overdo it and lose the game for his team after the reg. season San Diego game.
Done for Ryan and Flacco.
I can understand the sentiment on Leinart, but both Smith and Young actually made contributions of some substance the past season even though Young's numbers weren't wowzers and Smith needs to play in a spread system. Perhaps he should be just "doubtful" instead of "very doubtful".
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by tryfuhl
I'd swap McNabb and Rodgers
|
I think McNabb is treading dangerously close to "still-good has been". If he gets traded to somewhere like Oakland, he certainly will be going there soon. He also is more inconsistent; he goes into periods of utter suckitude sometimes.