Quote:
Originally Posted by saden1
If effectiveness assessments are based on the 10 other players on the field with him I don't know who you can put much stock in value assessments and effectively compare Vincent Jackson to Brandon Marshall or any other two players.
Personally I believe in "Plug a Player and Play™" which is a subjective measurement of a players ability to come in and play at a high "Alpha Gorilla Level™" for any team.
|
Well, you make a very interesting point, because if the argument between two players isn't completely academic, then they do have to produce consistently in the context of their offenses.
I figured that people already know that the Broncos passing offense is blown away by the Chargers. When you look at mediocre passing offenses, look no further than the Broncos from 2006-2009. When you want to look at the best in the league over the same timeframe, look no further than the Chargers.
Of course, people will always look at the quarterback and the offensive line and the coaching staff before looking at WR no. 1, as rightly they should. But that doesn't mean that there isn't enough difference to go around here. The Chargers have proven better at nearly every offensive position than the Broncos since 2006, with a possible exception to the offensive line.
I think the Chargers OL has been underrated, but the Broncos --save 2009-- has been one of the best.