Quote:
Originally Posted by CultBrennan59
Cams a great QB, but the majority of football people are/were more on Andrew Luck than Cam ever was....Keep in mind, you and I are two guys on the internet giving our Opinions over who's better, when there are guys out there in the NFL, ESPN, NFL Network, etc who get paid for giving their opinion for a reason. And all those guys are still all about Luck. Even after Newton had his great rookie year, they said Cam's did great lets see how great Luck and RG3 are going to be. I agree, lets see.
|
I get the feeling your not even reading my post because you don't respond to any of the points I make and we're just going around in circles.
Here are my points:
(a) the 'majority of football people' are draft media talking heads
they are not scouts
(b) they draft media is wrong all the time therefore when you prop a player up based on there opinion you're just relying on the opinion of people who have been proven wrong time and time again as recently as last year
(c) [from watching your clip] even after Cam had a great rookie year
some are saying that Luck is still better but
some are not as evident by the debate you posted 2 guys on the panel are actually making my point. But that line of logic or rhetoric behind that debate is based on the persistence of an inaccurate/wrong headed evaluation that the same draft media made of Cam in the first place
And finally (for the 3rd time); since we are just 2 guys on the internet having a discussion why don't you tell me the areas
you think Luck is better then Cam and Griff based on their NFL skillset? (instead of pushing the opinions of the often and recently wrong draft media?)...is it arm strength, timing, deep ball, pro-readiness, accuracy, efficiency, size, playmaking