Quote:
Originally Posted by Dirtbag59
I forget the exact order but I think my list of best rookie QB's before was as follows.
1. RG3
2. Dan Marino
3. Big Ben
4. Matt Ryan
5. Cam Newton
Now with Luck and Wilson playing as well as they have I don't know what to do, though I do feel confident bumping Newton off. And I think I can at least put Wilson above Ryan, the real question is should he go above Marino and Big Ben. Though I still say Luck should be below Ryan. F it I'll do it.
1. RG3
2. Wilson
3. Marino
4. Big Ben
5. Matt Ryan
6. Cam Newton
7. Andrew Luck
At the very least they're all in the top tier as far as rookie QB's are concerned.
|
I won't argue against any of your post. Couldn't come up with a better list myself. Just to nitpick your list though :cheeky-sm would Peyton fall anywhere in there? (as a rookie, trying to not think of his career overall)