Andy Reid or Mike Shanahan? Eagles President takes shot at Shanny

[skinsfaninok]

Banner: If Mike Shanahan can win two Super Bowls, Andy Reid can too | ProFootballTalk

I think Reid is a good coach but should he have won "multiple super bowls"? I don't know about that. Seems like the pressure is as big as ever for him in Philly. I don't see him winning a title there

[Dirtbag59]

Maybe if he hadn't wasted 10 years with McNabb he would have won one by now.

[Chico23231]

Seriously, F*ck the Eagles. 0 Superbowls, so f*ck off Banner.

[BuckSkin]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

Seriously, F*ck the Eagles. 0 Superbowls, so f*ck off Banner.

Really Chico, you have the lingual heart of a Philly fan.

[Hog1]

You are what your record says you are.......Bill Parcells
The Eagles owner is a Dick...........Bill Parcells

[TIFOSOdeiREDSKINS]

if joe schmoe fat body on "the biggest loser" can lose 40 pounds, andy reid can too.

[CultBrennan59]

Originally Posted by Dirtbag359

Maybe if he hadn't wasted 10 years with McNabb he would have won one by now.

Haha Daaaammmnn!

[44ever]

Reid is to blame for losing Big games because his play calling gets so dam conservative in the Playoffs, McNabb cant play under pressure either. They certainly had many many SB quality teams thru the years. I define Reid as a better than average coach, nothing more.
Shanny proved he could go all the way so there is nothing that can be said.

[Ruhskins]

Reid and the Eagles wasted McNabb in his prime by not giving him good receivers (until TO), running TO out of town, and not getting a good short yardage/goal line running game. I think at best, they have two years to get to the big game...probably just one more though it seemed like the only way they won was by getting Vick beat up.

[JPPT1974]

Well wonder what will happen in 2011? If either McNabb stays at QB as you know he won't be or take being a backup. Despite McNabb's injuries getting in the way. He has a year or two ahead of him that is good if given the opportunity. Grossman is an average QB but not elite. He is better off as a backup.

[SirClintonPortis]

McNabb - Illusions of grandeur. Lying scum. Overrated. Better than departed incumbent(Campbell)
Shanahans - Illusions of grandeur. Lying scum. Overrated. Better than departed incumbents(Snyder, Vinny, Zorn).

[SolidSnake84]

McNabb cost Reid alot of big games...no doubt about it. Seeing this year that a still semi-rusty Michael Vick takes the team to the playoffs when he didnt even start the first couple of games says to me that they definatley have a great chance at a superbowl. Andy Reid is a much better coach and talent evaluator than what people give him credit for.

[MTK]

Plenty of good coaches don't win it all, I think Reid will fall under that category.

I didn't really take this as a shot at Shanahan as much as he's just proclaiming his faith in his own guy. I don't think the intention was to crap on MS's accomplishments necessarily. That said I'm sure MS will be filing this one away.

[skinsfan69]

Andy Reid is a damn good football coach. One thing I like about him is he seems to be able to relate and communicate with his players. They seem to respect him. He knows when to put a foot in their ass and he knows when to lay off. Not to mention he's done great things with Vick and McNabb. I've always liked him a lot. So far, from the one year I've seen from Shanahan, I'm just not that impressed with the guy. Right now, I'm taking Reid over Shanahan.

[CrustyRedskin]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

Andy Reid is a damn good football coach. One thing I like about him is he seems to be able to relate and communicate with his players. They seem to respect him. He knows when to put a foot in their ass and he knows when to lay off. Not to mention he's done great things with Vick and McNabb. I've always liked him a lot. So far, from the one year I've seen from Shanahan, I'm just not that impressed with the guy. Right now, I'm taking Reid over Shanahan.

Well put, i agree in full!!!