Top 10 QBs

[HailGreen28]

Jay and Eli don't belong on the list.

Top Ten:
Peyton
Aaron
Tom
Drew
Ben
Phillip
"Matty"
Colin
Tony
Matthew

I would consider Robert, Andrew, and Russell; but I don't think they've played enough to belong on the list yet.

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by HailGreen28

Jay and Eli don't belong on the list.

Top Ten:
Peyton
Aaron
Tom
Drew
Ben
Phillip
"Matty"
Colin
Tony
Matthew

I would consider Robert, Andrew, and Russell; but I don't think they've played enough to belong on the list yet.

So why Ben but not Eli ?

[HailGreen28]

Originally Posted by Giantone

So why Ben but not Eli ?

The pounding Ben has had to take to do what other QBs have done.

Ben is one of many QBs that has looked his best in his non-SB years.

I guess if we were ranking QBs by tendency for interceptions, Brett and Eli would be among the top 5 all time.

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by Giantone

So why Ben but not Eli ?

lol...that train is never late.

Eli is a good QB, but if you look at some of his numbers he is wildly inconsistent and it goes in cycles. Its really strange. He plays like a top 5 QB, leading 4th quarter comebacks and then he will lead the league in interceptions, fumbles, turnovers.

I think Eli is really like most QB, their life is made alot easier with a solid running game and a top half of the league defense.

[artmonkforhallofamein07]

Originally Posted by HailGreen28

Jay and Eli don't belong on the list.

Top Ten:
Peyton
Aaron
Tom
Drew
Ben
Phillip
"Matty"
Colin
Tony
Matthew

I would consider Robert, Andrew, and Russell; but I don't think they've played enough to belong on the list yet.

Why Kapernick over the other three? He has been pretty average at best this year, And until I see more from both III and Wilson neither one belong on this list. The only young guy I would even consider right now is Luck. The other three haven't done much of anything this year. CK also has a smaller sample size of games over the other three. Last years rookies started all 16 games (well minus the one griff missed) and CK started 7 games + the 3 playoff games. And honestly even with Griffin struggles he has been the worst of the 4 this year.

[HailGreen28]

Originally Posted by artmonkforhallofamein07

Why Kapernick over the other three? He has been pretty average at best this year, And until I see more from both III and Wilson neither one belong on this list. The only young guy I would even consider right now is Luck. The other three haven't done much of anything this year. CK also has a smaller sample size of games over the other three. Last years rookies started all 16 games (well minus the one griff missed) and CK started 7 games + the 3 playoff games. And honestly even with Griffin struggles he has been the worst of the 4 this year.

I was really impressed by the times I've seen Kaepernick play, but yeah this year he sure doesn't look that good.