The First "hope we lose" Gameday thread !!

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by jamf

Best outcome.
This puts the Sam Howell argument to bed, we need a qb.
We preserve draft position.

Go ALL IN for Caleb or Drake Maye.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[PorkSkins]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

Go ALL IN for Caleb or Drake Maye.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Nope. I'm not sold at all on Caleb Williams and I think Maye could be the hype of overdraft. I'd rather go with an OT.

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by PorkSkins

Nope. I'm not sold at all on Caleb Williams and I think Maye could be the hype of overdraft. I'd rather go with an OT.

You have to take one of them. This team has no franchise player. Draft the Rookie in a loaded rookie class for QBs


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[PorkSkins]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

You have to take one of them. This team has no franchise player. Draft the Rookie in a loaded rookie class for QBs


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

No you don't have to take one of 'em. There's nothing written where you have to take either of them. I'm not a fan of Williams and think Maye would be someone who's over drafted at #4. You don't know if a QB will be a franchise player no more than I know an OT will be one. But I'll wager the latter would be one before the former. Even more so considering I'm not exactly sold on either of the mentioned QBs.

The "franchise player" or better pick at #4 would be an OT. A likely anchor on the line who'll be with us for 10 or more years.

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by PorkSkins

No you don't have to take one of 'em. There's nothing written where you have to take either of them. I'm not a fan of Williams and think Maye would be someone who's over drafted at #4. You don't know if a QB will be a franchise player no more than I know an OT will be one. But I'll wager the latter would be one before the former. Even more so considering I'm not exactly sold on either of the mentioned QBs.

The "franchise player" or better pick at #4 would be an OT. A likely anchor on the line who'll be with us for 10 or more years.

It’s also a very real possibility that both are gone by 4..


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

It’s also a very real possibility that both are gone by 4..


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I guarantee they are both gone by pick 4. Jayden Daniels, Michael Penix Jr are the next two in the order of prospects if you go QB.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by PorkSkins

No you don't have to take one of 'em. There's nothing written where you have to take either of them. I'm not a fan of Williams and think Maye would be someone who's over drafted at #4. You don't know if a QB will be a franchise player no more than I know an OT will be one. But I'll wager the latter would be one before the former. Even more so considering I'm not exactly sold on either of the mentioned QBs.

The "franchise player" or better pick at #4 would be an OT. A likely anchor on the line who'll be with us for 10 or more years.

Hey remember the last 20 plus years how we've had elite LT for the majority of that and did nothing with it? Now in that same timeframe you see how we've had a game changing offensive player for 1 year? QB will always be more important than LT when both are equal.

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by EARTHQUAKE2689

Hey remember the last 20 plus years how we've had elite LT for the majority of that and did nothing with it? Now in that same timeframe you see how we've had a game changing offensive player for 1 year? QB will always be more important than LT when both are equal.

Exactly. You can find a good LT in later rounds , Trent Williams made us all spoiled but how many rings does he have?? Zero so far and he’s 34.

In the NFL you need a top 10 QB consistently to be good every yr. We have never had that and you have to keep trying until you find one.

Caleb Williams is compared to Mahomes , Aaron Rodgers level.

Drake Maye is being compared to the likes of Justin Herbert and Carson Palmer.

They both are good with big time ceilings.

Will they both end up Great? You don’t know but you can’t pass that potential up.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[PorkSkins]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

Exactly. You can find a good LT in later rounds , Trent Williams made us all spoiled but how many rings does he have?? Zero so far and he’s 34.

In the NFL you need a top 10 QB consistently to be good every yr. We have never had that and you have to keep trying until you find one.

Caleb Williams is compared to Mahomes , Aaron Rodgers level.

Drake Maye is being compared to the likes of Justin Herbert and Carson Palmer.

They both are good with big time ceilings.

Will they both end up Great? You don’t know but you can’t pass that potential up.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

You believe in hype as I've seen enough of your posts. We'll agree to disagree on this one.

[PorkSkins]

Originally Posted by EARTHQUAKE2689

Hey remember the last 20 plus years how we've had elite LT for the majority of that and did nothing with it? Now in that same timeframe you see how we've had a game changing offensive player for 1 year? QB will always be more important than LT when both are equal.

I'm not actually sold on either one and think Maye will be a player who'll be overdrafted.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by PorkSkins

I'm not actually sold on either one and think Maye will be a player who'll be overdrafted.

If I am being completely honest, I'd take Marvin Harrison Jr. if available at 4 before I took the LT. Id turn right around and take either Mims of Fontunau in the 2nd with one of the two second rounders

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by PorkSkins

Nope. I'm not sold at all on Caleb Williams and I think Maye could be the hype of overdraft. I'd rather go with an OT.

Would not be entirely a bad idea. I actually tend to agree with it. Let JB come back. Strengthen the team around him. Find a quarterback elsewhere or in next years draft. A QB should not be taken if he is just going to get killed.