The annual NFL coaching carousel

[NC_Skins]

Originally Posted by BaltimoreSkins

Since we don't have a conference weekend thread. IMO if McDermott doesn't win this game he is done. How long do you give a coach that can't win that one game every year?

He's 0-4 against the Chiefs in the playoffs. I get it the refs are definitely on the Chiefs side, but you gotta at least ONE of those games. He can't do it.

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by BaltimoreSkins

Since we don't have a conference weekend thread. IMO if McDermott doesn't win this game he is done. How long do you give a coach that can't win that one game every year?

Agreed. I think he should have been fired a year or two ago.

[sdskinsfan2001]

I don't want any more coaches to get fired. Kliff and Josh Allen could be a thing. I'd rather run it back with our offense next year.

But wow, being a Bills fan would be terrible. You know your team is NEVER going to win a super bowl. They are professional losers. They're like the heel in wrestling.

[WCommandersfan99]

I still don't think Buffalo fires McDermott. He's gotten so close just can't get over the hump. Chiefs dynasty is no joke at all, and McDermott and the Bills are trying to get their ring during it. Again would be very surprised if McDermott is gone in Buffalo.

[BaltimoreSkins]

This scene from X files

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=1XG2WdP2R4U

[AnonEmouse]

On the one hand I can see the argument if you can't get over the last hurdle, we look for someone who can, there's the consideration of what message the organisation sends sacking the guy that got them to the championship game again. I'd be surprised if they fire him now, but maybe not renew his contract when the time comes. I think it depends on his relationship with the whole organisation; do you want to be rebuilding a coaching staff, break relationships between the current staff, players and FO and rebuild those, and all after being 1 drive away from the SB. It's a big call.

[Frost]

best news today

"Breaking: #Commanders OC Kliff Kingsbury — despite interest from the #Saints and other teams — has decided to stay in Washington for a second season following a remarkable turnaround that saw the team go from 4 wins to an NFC Championship appearance.

His return ensures continuity for the Commanders’ offense heading into 2025. Kingsbury will be a top HC candidate again next year, but the opportunity in Washington was too good to walk away from now."

[WCommandersfan99]

Originally Posted by Frost

best news today

"Breaking: #Commanders OC Kliff Kingsbury — despite interest from the #Saints and other teams — has decided to stay in Washington for a second season following a remarkable turnaround that saw the team go from 4 wins to an NFC Championship appearance.

His return ensures continuity for the Commanders’ offense heading into 2025. Kingsbury will be a top HC candidate again next year, but the opportunity in Washington was too good to walk away from now."

This is awesome news. He was huge in this team's success. KK is great with offense and qbs. Hope this is long term but will gladly take 2025 as an assurance at this point.

[sdskinsfan2001]

Not leaving Jayden Daniels for Saints Cap Hell:

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by Frost

best news today

"Breaking: #Commanders OC Kliff Kingsbury — despite interest from the #Saints and other teams — has decided to stay in Washington for a second season following a remarkable turnaround that saw the team go from 4 wins to an NFC Championship appearance.

His return ensures continuity for the Commanders’ offense heading into 2025. Kingsbury will be a top HC candidate again next year, but the opportunity in Washington was too good to walk away from now."

It's good to see this, but I am not surprised. AZ is still paying Kliff HC coach money and I'm sure he's getting a nice paycheck from the Commanders. He has turned down NFL jobs before, and will likely be very picky if/when he decides to be a HC again.

[88Commanders00]

Mike McCarthy will sit out 25 and try again in 26. He only had interviews with Bears and Saints. Speculation is Saints will hire Kellen Moore , whom they just interviewed but can’t hire him until after the Superbowl.

[sdskinsfan2001]

Originally Posted by 88Commanders00

Mike McCarthy will sit out 25 and try again in 26. He only had interviews with Bears and Saints. Speculation is Saints will hire Kellen Moore , whom they just interviewed but can’t hire him until after the Superbowl.

McCarthy obviously knows its a good ole boys game. Someone will hire him in 2026 because...that's it....just because.

[MTK]

KK is playing his cards right. Another gem of season here with JD and he will have teams falling over themselves to hire him. Plus as Ruhskins said he's being paid very well right now. No need to rush to move on.

[AnonEmouse]

Depends on his exact motivation. Getting a ring as priority, or simply being a successful HC. Wherever he goes now (NO really the only opening) he'd have to all but start from scratch, so at least 2-3 years away from a ring. He was 1 game away from the SB this year, so he's more likely to get to the big one here than with any other opening. Me, I'd want a SB ring then leverage that into a top HC job.

[88Commanders00]

While we wait for the Saints to likely hire Kellen Moore after the Superbowl; here’s a look at the 25 hot seat.

Giants- Brian Daboll and his GM Joe Schoen are on the hottest seats. Given the nfc east has 2 playoff capable teams and 3, if Dallas bounces back; Giants are destined for a Top 5 pick again. 2025 is almost certainly their last year.

Panthers- Young finally showed some life after he came back from his benching. The Panthers should be better, as long as Young continues to improve. If he reverts, Tepper will ax Canales. Also, how much improvement does Tepper expect? They won’t be a playoff team in 25 but should be better. Will that keep Tepper happy.

Browns- Really depends what they do at QB. Do they draft a qb? Watson likely will miss time in 25 and he’s done. Do they take the pain and cut him now? Stefanski’s future depends on what they do. The Watson deal screws them over for 2 more years.

Steelers- No, Tomlin won’t be fired but eventually Rooney might decide it’s better to move on from Tomlin. A mutual parting could finally happen, if they don’t get a playoff win or Tomlin finally has a losing season.

Colts- Irsay maybe getting tired of Shane Steichen not making playoffs and Anthony Richardson is likely a bust.

Titans- Callahan was almost one and done. What they do at qb is vital. Do they run it with Will Levis, who’s likely a bust? Draft a QB with their #1 pick.

Bills- Another season not in the Superbowl and McDermott may finally be let go, especially if he loses to Chiefs in playoffs again.

Dolphins- McDaniel hasn’t done much. Yeah, he made playoffs his first 2 years but they were quick exits. He slipped to 8-9 in 24. They probably need a playoff win for him to return.

I listed 8 potential changes but doubtful it’s that high, probably on the low side for 25. Only one that seems a lock; is the Giants.