Manning's bad cold-weather QBs?

[STPainmaker]

I think I agree eventhough the evidence is all anecdotal. I gotta say that living in NY I am often subjected to Giants games and I have noticed something about Eli he often misses his receivers by throwing way above their heads. Not floaters per se but simply throwing the ball several feet over his receiver.

I don't know if this is a function of him having Plaxico and Shockey to throw to, inexperience, or maybe a mechanics issues.