Grade Rocky McIntosh

[D'BOYZ]

Originally Posted by warriorzpath

Gibbs is defining his own style of personnel decisions. Because of his style, nfl experts cannot evaluate the redskins draft on its own anymore, they must evaluate the entire offseason as a whole without separating any part of it (draft, free agency, trades, cuts, salary cap based decisions, coaching staff additions/changes). All of these areas of personnel decision-making affects each other as a whole. He is an innovator in these decisions, this approach, and (don't forget) the role and responsibilities he has set for himself as head coach and team president.

Look first I don't disagree with you on what gibbs has brought to your team he has made great personel desicion has brought via FA excellent players that fit his style and has made your team competitive and hungry again.

Also your team has brought a new way of cap manegemnt to he NFL that has let them bring the player they want each year withou mayor consecuences that also is true.

but in thsi case you have to saparete what he has been doing in FA and the draft because they haven't merge yet if let's say gibbs had traded this year second round pick to the Jets for moss instead of coles then yes there would be a relation. but no the only way to compare and evaluate his draft moves is based only on the draft and hsi draft pics because he has only traded draft pics he hasn't merge the 2 sides of the bussnises get FA/ trades/ draft.

offcourse your FA pics affect what would you do i nthe draft as it does with every other team like Archuleta took a SS need aways from the draft but it doesn't determine the moves you make during the draft.

Like the 1 you did and the reason that I call these type of moves (giving away future high picks) risky or a disaster waiting to happen is because of history look 2 years ago is that easy Bufallo traded with us their low 2nd round a 5th and last year first for our 22 in the first round. How did it tur out? well got JJ, Spears and Ryan (an eventually Bledose because he was released because of JP losman) and Buffalo only got Losman 2 years later JJ , Spears and Bledsoe are starters in our team and Losman is a backup and has been almost been shown the door with a lot of speculation from the Bills that want to trade him.