Redskins-Giants: Defensive Review

[hesscl34]

Originally Posted by Mattyk72

Guess you saw a different game. Or maybe the hater glasses are clouding your vision.

I'm not a "hater" just becuase I've seen little imporovment in a player that's been around for a quite a few years. Injury or no injury he's no better or worse then the day he got off the bus. Until I see change, I don't think I'll agree with you..

.. and do the board a favor and stop calling people names (implied or not) just becuase they don't agree with you.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by hesscl34

I'm not a "hater" just becuase I've seen little imporovment in a player that's been around for a quite a few years. Injury or no injury he's no better or worse then the day he got off the bus. Until I see change, I don't think I'll agree with you..

.. and do the board a favor and stop calling people names (implied or not) just becuase they don't agree with you.

Hess, trust me, the improvement is there.

If you don't have any games taped from 2006, I really can't show you the mistakes that CR was making back then, that he's not making now. But I can suggest you watch Packers-Vikings tonight. Hold Charles Woodson/Al Harris/Antoine Winfield to the same standard you hold Rogers to. I think you'll be surprised how often a top corner in the NFL gets beaten.

[MTK]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Hess, trust me, the improvement is there.

If you don't have any games taped from 2006, I really can't show you the mistakes that CR was making back then, that he's not making now. But I can suggest you watch Packers-Vikings tonight. Hold Charles Woodson/Al Harris/Antoine Winfield to the same standard you hold Rogers to. I think you'll be surprised how often a top corner in the NFL gets beaten.

Trust me, she's not going to listen. Good try though.

[hesscl34]

Originally Posted by Mattyk72

Trust me, she's not going to listen. Good try though.

Pot calling the kettle black again?

[hesscl34]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Hess, trust me, the improvement is there.

If you don't have any games taped from 2006, I really can't show you the mistakes that CR was making back then, that he's not making now. But I can suggest you watch Packers-Vikings tonight. Hold Charles Woodson/Al Harris/Antoine Winfield to the same standard you hold Rogers to. I think you'll be surprised how often a top corner in the NFL gets beaten.

OK, I'll take your word for it and hope you are right.. but like I said I'm giving him until gamem 5 to be sure.

[MTK]

Originally Posted by hesscl34

I'm not a "hater" just becuase I've seen little imporovment in a player that's been around for a quite a few years. Injury or no injury he's no better or worse then the day he got off the bus. Until I see change, I don't think I'll agree with you..

.. and do the board a favor and stop calling people names (implied or not) just becuase they don't agree with you.

If you honestly saw no improvement, you either didn't watch the game very closely or you just have something against the guy.

[hesscl34]

Originally Posted by Mattyk72

If you honestly saw no improvement, you either didn't watch the game very closely or you just have something against the guy.

Yep, that's it. I have something against Rogers. It's personal... .

I watched the game and saw nothing other than what I've seen before. He did defend on occassion, but he also got beat... a lot. I'm reserving judgment until game 5. I think that will give him enough play time to really say if he's improved or not.