Giants add lineman Shawn Andrews

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by CultBrennan59

he'll probably be cut soon, out of football shape is never a good thing.

.....does that include D linemen also?

[GMScud]

He's injury prone and a major head case. There's a reason a relatively young former pro-bowler wasn't on anyone's roster until now. Nothing to see here.

[artmonkforhallofamein07]

Originally Posted by Giantone

.....does that include D linemen also?

Ouch. Let's just wait and see about AH, he is a stud and will get this thing going in the coming weeks.

Comparing a guy who has been out of football and wanted to quit the game to a guy who wants to play is wrong.

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by artmonkforhallofamein07

Comparing a guy who has been out of football and wanted to quit the game to a guy who wants to play is wrong.

Andrews has had his problems but I don't think he ever quit(retire) ,he has had a back problem and AH has had a knee problem ,Andrews has a actual illness diagnosis of Depression..treatable big AH has a ........,well it's not diagnose...yet but he has something, so yeah they are alike but SA only cost the Giants a guarantee of 250,000 signing bonus been to 2 pro bowls and at least will help as a back up or with the younger linemen.

[GMScud]

Originally Posted by Giantone

Andrews has had his problems but I don't think he ever quit(retire) ,he has had a back problem and AH has had a knee problem ,Andrews has a actual illness diagnosis of Depression..treatable big AH has a ........,well it's not diagnose...yet but he has something, so yeah they are alike but SA only cost the Giants a guarantee of 250,000 signing bonus been to 2 pro bowls and at least will help as a back up or with the younger linemen.

Why the arbitrary need to compare Andrews to Hanyesworth? Anything to feel better about the signing I guess.

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by GMScud

Why the arbitrary need to compare Andrews to Hanyesworth? Anything to feel better about the signing I guess.

LOL....nope not at all.Just responding to post #11

[GMScud]

Originally Posted by Giantone

LOL....nope not at all.Just responding to post #11

oops