Top 10 QBs

[HailGreen28]

Originally Posted by artmonkforhallofamein07

Why Kapernick over the other three? He has been pretty average at best this year, And until I see more from both III and Wilson neither one belong on this list. The only young guy I would even consider right now is Luck. The other three haven't done much of anything this year. CK also has a smaller sample size of games over the other three. Last years rookies started all 16 games (well minus the one griff missed) and CK started 7 games + the 3 playoff games. And honestly even with Griffin struggles he has been the worst of the 4 this year.

I was really impressed by the times I've seen Kaepernick play, but yeah this year he sure doesn't look that good.

[Kindoy]

1. Peyton
2. Brady
3a. Rodgers
3b. Brees
5. Big Ben
6. Eli
7. Matt Ryan
8. Romo
9. Luck
10. Stafford / Rivers

Done from the perspective of "If I had one season to win a Superbowl who would I want as my QB?"

Good thread! Could be done for other positions when this one dies out.

[The Goat]

In order of awesomeness:

1) P. Manning
2) Breesus
3) Rodgers
4) Brady
5) Luck
6) Stafford
7) Ryan
8) P. Mannings retarded little brother
9) Wilson
10) Rothlesburger

I hate putting Ben on the list because he's a scumbag, but he's earned it on the field.

Wilson gets the nod because he does everything and in this era of mobile QBs he's doing it the best all around. RG could be there but he's too careless this far, in more ways than one.

[MTK]

I was really impressed with Cutler last night, mainly his decision making. I'm sure it helps that his OL is much improved too.

[CultBrennan59]

Originally Posted by Mattyk

I was really impressed with Cutler last night, mainly his decision making. I'm sure it helps that his OL is much improved too.

Exactly. No QB would be good or put up good numbers with the OL he was behind for the past 3 years.

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by Mattyk

I was really impressed with Cutler last night, mainly his decision making. I'm sure it helps that his OL is much improved too.

Agreed. He's playing solid ball. Trestman seems to be a good influence on him.

[skinsfaninok]

^ It's called last yr he came out of no where and he has some speed so he just scared everyone, Now teams are making him pass and he's not that great of a passer.. Again Ron Jaworski will never be reliable imo anymore when it comes to QB predictions. The fact that he said CK may be the greatest QB ever to play is just mind blowing to me

I mean I'll be honest I don't see a big difference in him and Terrell Pryor

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

^ It's called last yr he came out of no where and he has some speed so he just scared everyone, Now teams are making him pass and he's not that great of a passer.. Again Ron Jaworski will never be reliable imo anymore when it comes to QB predictions. The fact that he said CK may be the greatest QB ever to play is just mind blowing to me

I mean I'll be honest I don't see a big difference in him and Terrell Pryor

Um...he was a big reason they almost won the SB. He's had some injuries around him ...that's probably one of the reasons he's played poorly. Everyone needs to remember he hasn't even started 16 games. But he's also absolutely dominated some games as well. I think he comes around. The talent level is just too high.

[Mechanix544]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

Um...he was a big reason they almost won the SB. He's had some injuries around him ...that's probably one of the reasons he's played poorly. Everyone needs to remember he hasn't even started 16 games. But he's also absolutely dominated some games as well. I think he comes around. The talent level is just too high.

I dont want to hear about a couple injuries on that stacked ass team. ANY QB should be able to step in and be moderately productive in SF, they have a wonderful squad.

Kapernick is just not as good as everyone thinks. NOW RG3 has a myriad of excuses. OLine, horrible defense, TORN ACL MCL returning in less that 9 months from a second total reconstruction, no preseason, his RT lol, ...............RG3 will be just fine, and I expect him in a couple weeks to perform like he hasn't missed a beat. Kapernick just isnt as good as RG3, and now the gimmicks are wearing thin, and the rest of the squad can't cover up his mediocrity anymore.

[skinsfan69]

Is this through 5 games this year?? Cause if so no way is Flacco, Ben, Eli and RG3 in the top 10.

[skinsfaninok]

^ Alex Smith should have taken that same team to the SB the yr before, yeah CK had a nice run last yr but I'm sticking with the fact that hes not a Franchise QB, sorry but the numbers prove it.. And Y does he get a pass but RG3 doesn't?

[skinsfaninok]

and No there really isn't a difference in both players games

Pryor is the same player as CK