The Legitimacy of Super Bowls 17 & 22

[CrustyRedskin]

Originally Posted by Alvin Walton

I wonder if Archie knew his wifes uterus was going to be a quarterback factory.

Those two are are so abnormal and im kind of a conspiracy theorist so i got a hunch they were butt babies. Kinda Xmenish.

[budw38]

Originally Posted by Alvin Walton

I wonder if Archie knew his wifes uterus was going to be a quarterback factory.

LOL , maybe a new wing will be in the Pro Football Hall of fame . " This is were Peyton and Eli are from "

[HailGreen28]

The legitimacy of the next few seasons for the Giants can be called into question. The cheating Giants owner illegally and unfairly took cap space from 2 out of 3 divisional opponents two straight seasons. And only got away with it because the head of the players union cared more about keeping his job rather than fighting for the players.

Cheaters like Mara and his team don't deserve positive recognition.

[Bishop Hammer]

Awww screw the Giants. They win a couple Superbowls recently and now they have big heads.

Why some Skins fans rooted for them in their SB's abainst the Pats is beyond me? No matter how you felt about NE the Giants are division rivals. I don't want them to do well no matter who they play. I dislike NY more than Dallas at this point. Here's hoping the Skins even the series in the rematch.

[REDSKINS4ever]

I do agree that the NYG fan base heads have swelled because of those 2 Super Bowl wins over Brady and NE. But they met their match yesterday even though the managed to win the game.

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by REDSKINS4ever

I do agree that the NYG fan base heads have swelled because of those 2 Super Bowl wins over Brady and NE. But they met their match yesterday even though the managed to win the game.

.....and that never would have happen in Washington,ever.

[REDSKINS4ever]

Originally Posted by Giantone

.....and that never would have happen in Washington,ever.

Only if those Washington teams were great 14-2/13-3/12-4 etc. The NYG teams that won Super Bowls 42 & 46 were not great teams. They were 10-6 and 9-7 going into the playoffs those years. Especially the 2011 NYG team that at one point had a 4 game losing streak and a little luck within the post season. Their credibility in the SB comes from already have beaten the Patriots in New England during the regular season that year. But I don't see how a fan base can brag and boast about a lowly above average team that were fortunate to win out. They were nothing like the Saints and Packers in 2011.

[MTK]

Originally Posted by REDSKINS4ever

Only if those Washington teams were great 14-2/13-3/12-4 etc. The NYG teams that won Super Bowls 42 & 46 were not great teams. They were 10-6 and 9-7 going into the playoffs those years. Especially the 2011 NYG team that at one point had a 4 game losing streak and a little luck within the post season. Their credibility in the SB comes from already have beaten the Patriots in New England during the regular season that year. But I don't see how a fan base can brag and boast about a lowly above average team that were fortunate to win out. They were nothing like the Saints and Packers in 2011.

You're really not helping your case here at all.

You want Giants fans to respect our wins in strike shortened years, but you're discrediting their wins by saying they were lucky or didn't have a great W/L record? Makes no sense.

[REDSKINS4ever]

Originally Posted by Mattyk

You're really not helping your case here at all.

You want Giants fans to respect our wins in strike shortened years, but you're discrediting their wins by saying they were lucky or didn't have a great W/L record? Makes no sense.

Mattyk, I don't like the Giants and I'm beginning to dislike them more than the Cowboys, believe it or not. You don't live up here in NYC like I do. I don't want and care for their respect. The way they see us is the way I see them.

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by REDSKINS4ever

Only if those Washington teams were great 14-2/13-3/12-4 etc. The NYG teams that won Super Bowls 42 & 46 were not great teams. They were 10-6 and 9-7 going into the playoffs those years. Especially the 2011 NYG team that at one point had a 4 game losing streak and a little luck within the post season. Their credibility in the SB comes from already have beaten the Patriots in New England during the regular season that year. But I don't see how a fan base can brag and boast about a lowly above average team that were fortunate to win out. They were nothing like the Saints and Packers in 2011.

wow, I now understand why you are having problems up in NY,I'm done.

[REDSKINS4ever]

Originally Posted by Giantone

wow, I now understand why you are having problems up in NY,I'm done.

Do you really? The Packers, 49ers, Saints and other NFC playoff teams were indeed good. The NYG on the other hand were lucky.

[coggs]

Originally Posted by REDSKINS4ever

Only if those Washington teams were great 14-2/13-3/12-4 etc. The NYG teams that won Super Bowls 42 & 46 were not great teams. They were 10-6 and 9-7 going into the playoffs those years. Especially the 2011 NYG team that at one point had a 4 game losing streak and a little luck within the post season. Their credibility in the SB comes from already have beaten the Patriots in New England during the regular season that year. But I don't see how a fan base can brag and boast about a lowly above average team that were fortunate to win out. They were nothing like the Saints and Packers in 2011.

In that case the 87 Redskins were nothing like the 85 Bears, 86 Giants, 84 Niners, 89 Niners, 90 Giants, 83 Raiders, 92 Cowboys, 93 Cowboys, 94 Niners, 95 Cowboys and so forth. What is your point? Seems like it is you who needs the convincing about the legitimacy of the Skins titles, not the Giants fans. In fact, I have never in my life ever heard a Giants fan make the claim to which you are accusing.

[REDSKINS4ever]

Originally Posted by coggs

In that case the 87 Redskins were nothing like the 85 Bears, 86 Giants, 84 Niners, 89 Niners, 90 Giants, 83 Raiders, 92 Cowboys, 93 Cowboys, 94 Niners, 95 Cowboys and so forth. What is your point? Seems like it is you who needs the convincing about the legitimacy of the Skins titles, not the Giants fans. In fact, I have never in my life ever heard a Giants fan make the claim to which you are accusing.

You failed to mention the 91 Redskins. Anyway, I hear that argument in New York City all the time from NYG fans. Not all of them, but those of them who claim to really know football. Once the NFL commissioner presents the Vince Lombardi trophy to an NFL organization, that alone legitimizes the SB victory, I tell them. It's sort of like a new world leader being sworn in.

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by Giantone

.....and that never would have happen in Washington,ever.

never, you wouldnt even know we won, because we would be so modest about it and never ever ever talk about it. ARE YOU EFFIN KIDDIN ME - my head is still big and swollen because of 70 chip!!!!! Please give me another big swollen head again - PLEASE!

are they supposed to be ashamed of it?

:confused:

edit: as for the strike teams well - only difference a full season would have made is a few more W's for us.

[Evilgrin]

This must be a troll....