Skinsfaninok's Available NFL QBs Poll

[Lotus]

Originally Posted by CultBrennan59

The strategy is lose now, win a lot later. I mean we're not winning the super bowl or going to the playoffs this year so, we might as well suck to get Luck

So, in your own words, the Redskins should lose. Got it, Cowboys fan.

[Alvin Walton]

Originally Posted by CultBrennan59

I mean god forbid we get a good player/QB that could turn this franchise around and be the next Elway... I mean who would want to win for once?

Any NFL coach who's strategy is to lose so he can win would get laughed out of the league in a New York minute.
Luck is just some kid in college....sure he has huge potential but so did Ryan Leaf and David Carr and Andre Ware.
Luck hasnt done anything in the NFL.....and he has a whole year for who knows what to go wrong....you would have to be nuts to tank a whole year based on what "some Kid" might do 16 months from. And its a far fetched crap shoot with a lot of variables to say today that we can take him in the next draft.

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by CultBrennan59

I mean god forbid we get a good player/QB that could turn this franchise around and be the next Elway... I mean who would want to win for once?

How is Andrew Luck the next Elway? The stanford connection? Sorry man but thats ridiculous.

[NYCskinfan82]

If we do get VY they will design certain packageS for him until he knows the Offense IMO.

[Swarley]

Maybe this is the kind of year where, if you want to win or minimize the adjustment period, you have to go with either a QB FA who knows the offense or you go with someone already on your roster. This kind of makes me think that all this Beck stuff isn't simply smokescreen.

[Meks]

I don't give a rats ass who he is I would hate to "tank it" ... its the pride principal

[Dirtbag59]

Best situation for the Skins right now would be to bring in Young under the guise of "You'll most likely be a backup for year 1 and if you do start you won't start before week 8." If you can get him to agree to sit in the background and learn the offense then bringing in Young is a golden opportunity. However if he comes in and they plug him in as the starter...well safe to say it'll probably be as ugly as McNabb last year.

[skinsfaninok]

People thought Ryan Leaf and Alex Smith were GREAT also

[Alvin Walton]

Suck to get Luck
Great mission statement for the team.

#Insert giant roll eyes icon here#

[Lotus]

Originally Posted by Alvin Walton

Suck to get Luck
Great mission statement for the team.

#Insert giant roll eyes icon here#

Well done. I might borrow that with your permission.

[NYCskinfan82]

So we should teach the 12 new draft picks we just got to loose, yeah that's the way to go, good habits to start forming.

[CultBrennan59]

Originally Posted by NYCskinfan82

So we should teach the 12 new draft picks we just got to loose, yeah that's the way to go, good habits to start forming.

Half of them won't be playing and will be busts or cut. And No, we could have them play out, because it's not like they're all going to be pro bowl caliber players that are game changers, maybe Kerrigan, but I think he'll have struggles moving from a hand in the dirt DE to a standup OLB.

[Lotus]

Originally Posted by CultBrennan59

Half of them won't be playing and will be busts or cut. And No, we could have them play out, because it's not like they're all going to be pro bowl caliber players that are game changers, maybe Kerrigan, but I think he'll have struggles moving from a hand in the dirt DE to a standup OLB.

So if you are going to remain true to your vision, then when we play the Cowboys you will be rooting for Dallas. When we play Philly you will root for the Pigeons. When we play NY you will root for the Dwarfs.

You will be just like other Redskin haters.

[Dirtbag59]

I love YouTube's filter system. Thanks to looking 20+ minute videos I was able to find one that shows every single Vince Young passing play. Completions, incompletions, Int's, scrambles, sacks, fumbles, you name it. If it happened in 2010 it's there. And the best part is this past year he played against the G-Men and Dallas. Obviously playing against us only means so much if we're looking at him and he was either hurt or benched for the Philly game.

[Hog1]

Originally Posted by Dirtbag59

I love YouTube's filter system. Thanks to looking 20+ minute videos I was able to find one that shows every single Vince Young passing play. Completions, incompletions, Int's, scrambles, sacks, fumbles, you name it. If it happened in 2010 it's there. And the best part is this past year he played against the G-Men and Dallas. Obviously playing against us only means so much if we're looking at him and he was either hurt or benched for the Philly game.

After viewing all that DB, what is your assessment?