Redskins Free Agency Thread

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by jamf

Who on the current Redskins roster would be a starter on that team?

Scherff over RC Thielmann and Hopkins over Zendejas are the only sure things IMO.

No love for Trent?

[jamf]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

No love for Trent?

Love TW but 86 Jacoby is better than 2019 Trent.

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by jamf

Love TW but 86 Jacoby is better than 2019 Trent.

Tress Way? I don’t remember the punter from 86 so maybe not and i know it is a punter.

[Buffalo Bob]

Originally Posted by punch it in

Tress Way? I don’t remember the punter from 86 so maybe not and i know it is a punter.

Place kickers and punters are usually an after thought on teams that have good offenses. I am a transplant Redskin fan since I moved east in 2011. I left my 40 years of 49er fandom in Cali when I left. I used to go to a couple 49er fan websites. Most the older guys like me (Late 50's on up) could not name one of the place kickers or punters on the 80's teams.

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by jamf

Love TW but 86 Jacoby is better than 2019 Trent.

naw...I love some Jacoby...But a healthy TW is a load and is an amazing athlete.

Silverback > Jacoby

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

naw...I love some Jacoby...But a healthy TW is a load and is an amazing athlete.

Silverback > Jacoby

I'm curious how people would rank:

Jacoby - Samuels - Trent

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by Ruhskins

I'm curious how people would rank:

Jacoby - Samuels - Trent

MAN...to be honest we've had some damn good tackles.

I like Trent over both, but Samuels and Jacoby are a toss up, probably lean Jacoby

[MTK]

I wouldn't leave out Lachey

[skinsfaninok]

I'd say it's safe that we all can agree on LT being the best position in Redskins history

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by MTK

I wouldn't leave out Lachey

Nope

[Schneed10]

Not so much lately, but we've had some damn good corners too. Darrell and Champ, even though Champ was a Bronco for longer than he was a Skin, those were four very good years.

[Defensewins]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

naw...I love some Jacoby...But a healthy TW is a load and is an amazing athlete.

Silverback > Jacoby

I am not sure the comparison is fair. They are both very different.
Jacoby was 6'7" 325 at a time very few were that big.
Plus he had the footspeed to pull on the counter trey like nobody else that size.
Jacoby used to battle one on one with Lawrence Taylor, Reggie White and Ed too Tall Jones twice a year.
I am not sure there is anyone in the NFC east right now that is as good as Lawrence Taylor and Reggie White.
When both are healthy TW is maybe a little better than Jacoby, but TW has had some knee problems that have made him miss some time and makes him susceptible to injury. Jacoby did not.
It is very close.

[DYoungJelly]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

MAN...to be honest we've had some damn good tackles.



I like Trent over both, but Samuels and Jacoby are a toss up, probably lean Jacoby

Trent is a physical freak and when healthy is the best athlete on the field.

He is the 1% of the 1%.

Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by MTK

I wouldn't leave out Lachey

Indeed. So my updated comparison list:

Lachey - Jacoby - Samuels - T. Williams

I think the case for Trent would be that a lot of people would put him and Tyrone Smith as the best tackles in the league. And yeah, we've had some damn good left tackles.

[VTSkins1961]

Originally Posted by MTK

I wouldn't leave out Lachey

He was great. Jay Schroeder for Jim Lachey - We made out out very well on that trade....