Re: Rocky trade is a possibility
 

What would Rocky be worth? We gave up picks to get him and now we are "possibly" shopping him? His play has been middle of the pack.

Re: Rocky trade is a possibility
 

I think the best we can probably hope for is to package him up with another player, on his own I don't see a team giving up much to get him.

Re: Rocky trade is a possibility
 

Reading Mel Kippers article from the Washington Post, it looks like there is Haynesworth, Campbell, Rocky, and Laundry all on the trading block. I just hope we end up with at least 7 or 8 picks someway.

Re: Rocky trade is a possibility
 

[quote=diehard;689608]We Traded up in a desperate move to draft LB McIntosh that year. And he has been solid considering injuries endured at the college level. Why trade him when you'd have to replace him? He's young and has earned an extension. Not a lucrative contract but, yes an extension.[/quote]

maybe we feel we can get a 2nd rounder for him..??? maybe get somebody like Spikes??? Not sure.

Re: Rocky trade is a possibility
 

A 2nd for Rocky?

Not gonna happen.

Re: Rocky trade is a possibility
 

Rocky is a good enough NFL linebacker, but I can't necessarily see a team that he would go to and start for, which limits his trade value.

If we released him, he'd get signed pretty quickly, but not for too much more than his tender offer.

Re: Rocky trade is a possibility
 

[quote=Mattyk;689645]A 2nd for Rocky?

Not gonna happen.[/quote]

Yup, not even close. I'd say more like a 5th.

Re: Rocky trade is a possibility
 

While I'm sure plenty of teams value Rocky at a 5th round pick, I doubt that any team will be willing to pull the trigger at that price. He's not getting an extension from that team, so what they are essentially getting at the price is a one year contract with a CBA dependent option for a second year.

Re: Rocky trade is a possibility
 

[quote=Mattyk;689645]A 2nd for Rocky?

Not gonna happen.[/quote]
So, what exactly do you expect from a 2nd round draft pick? Obviously you don't think a 4th or later round draft pick will best him.

Re: Rocky trade is a possibility
 

So who are we looking at as a possible trade partner. Only team I can think of is the Saints. Maybe the Eagles if we want to keep this "all in the division" thing going.

Re: Rocky trade is a possibility
 

[quote=diehard;689651]So, what exactly do you expect from a 2nd round draft pick? Obviously you don't think a 4th or later round draft pick will best him.[/quote]Might or might not, but when you make that draft pick, it comes with 4+ cheap years, and when you trade for Rocky, you get one. Which is the reason that if we shopped Rocky to all 31 teams, 27 would say they aren't interested in him at any price.

With the remaining 4 teams, it's all about deciding if the price they are going to give you is worth not having Rocky on the roster for this year. If the best offer you get is a seventh rounder...maybe you don't do that. Maybe you do. We will see.

Re: Rocky trade is a possibility
 

You guys are doing what this team has done for years... undervaluing your own players. That's a big mistake, for McIntosh and Campbell are solid value for their play on and off the field.

Re: Rocky trade is a possibility
 

[quote=diehard;689656]You guys are doing what this team has done for years... undervaluing your own players. That's a big mistake, for McIntosh and Campbell are solid value for their play on and off the field.[/quote]Well, I would argue that 1) you are correct, and that 2) this is Mike Shanahan's shortcoming.

This is also why I predict Rocky McIntosh will not be traded: we can't a nice return for him, so why not just let him play out the season here as (if nothing else) a nickel defender who can replace Fletch on third downs.

Re: Rocky trade is a possibility
 

[quote=diehard;689656]You guys are doing what this team has done for years... undervaluing your own players. That's a big mistake, for McIntosh and Campbell are solid value for their play on and off the field.[/quote]

This is opposed to what other team fans do with asking for second and third round picks for guys who we've never heard of. I mean if you think our bad you should see all the wonderful "forum offers" for Cooley that are out there from fans of other teams. It's like random player A, random player B, and a 4th round pick. Maybe we'll get lucky but I'm proud that our fan base is straying away from thinking like they're playing Madden. God knows they do it in so many other areas.

Re: Rocky trade is a possibility
 

[quote=diehard;689651]So, what exactly do you expect from a 2nd round draft pick? Obviously you don't think a 4th or later round draft pick will best him.[/quote]

I'm guessing he's a 5th round value, at best.